Check If Twitter Followers Are Fake

Check If Twitter Followers Are Fake
Check If Twitter Followers Are Fake Image link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiohead
C O N T E N T S:

KEY TOPICS

  • Just note that many Twitter users, especially large accounts, attract “fake” followers on their own.(More…)
  • The paper ran an extensive investigative report about the companies that sell Twitter followers and retweets, and the people who buy them.(More…)
  • If that segment of the American people is actually made up of inactive, fake, or innocuous accounts, Trump clearly reaches a far smaller audience of the American public than a casual look at his follower count on Twitter would suggest.(More…)
  • Some users boost the number of followers on the platform, and other services fed by Twitter, with either automated or fake accounts.(More…)
  • The leading social media companies are recognizing the dangers of fake followers and are creating new ways to check them.(More…)
  • The move comes in the wake of a January Times investigation into a follower farm, which Twitter executives say inspired the company to crack down on fake accounts.(More…)

POSSIBLY USEFUL

  • Twitter puts a limit on the number of accounts a user can follow until he or she has more followers.(More…)
  • They?re not backed by human actors, but neither are a large number of Twitter accounts that have been abandoned but still get counted.(More…)
  • Some federal and state lawmakers have called for more stringent laws regulating social media companies, in part to combat the epidemic of fake accounts.(More…)
  • The agency itself declined to comment but Marcus Holmlund, who managed the company?s social media efforts, told the Times he started making monthly purchases from Devumi after a supervisor told him to buy followers when the numbers weren?t growing fast enough.(More…)

RANKED SELECTED SOURCES

KEY TOPICS

Just note that many Twitter users, especially large accounts, attract “fake” followers on their own. [1] Why do fake followers even matter? With hundreds of millions of monthly active users, including the president of the United States and other important heads of state, Twitter has truly morphed from a microblogging platform into a method of communication that?s as accepted as a telephone. [1] TwitterAudit Pro is a tool to help you find and block fake followers on Twitter. [2]

The market for fakes was also hurting Twitter with advertisers, which increasingly rely on social media “influencers” — mini-celebrities who promote brands and products to their followers — to reach customers. [3] Social media in general, and Twitter in particular, is taking a huge hit after revelations that celebrities, politicians, athletes and influencers in all walks of life have boosted their social media following by buying fake Twitter followers. [4]

Many users have inflated their followers on Twitter or other services with automated or fake accounts, buying the appearance of social influence to bolster their political activism, business endeavors or entertainment careers. [3] In a series of articles in late January, the New York Times revealed the results of a lengthy investigation into fake Twitter accounts and how those accounts are sold to legitimate Twitter users to increase their number of followers and therefore their influence to advertisers and sponsors. [4] Just for fun, I ran a Twitter audit on President Donald Trump and it appears that only 51% of his followers are real, making almost half of them fake Twitter followers. [4] Among those found to have fake Twitter followers from Devumi were actor John Leguizamo, computer billionaire Michael Dell, American football commentator and former player Ray Lewis and Kathy Ireland, the onetime swimsuit model who today runs a multi-million-dollar licensing empire. [4]

The paper ran an extensive investigative report about the companies that sell Twitter followers and retweets, and the people who buy them. [5] Mr. Roeper bought at least 25,000 followers from Devumi, according to records reviewed by The Times, and an analysis of his account indicates that many of his nearly quarter-million Twitter followers are fake accounts. [6] The company’s heightened campaign against bots comes as federal lawmakers and law enforcement officials in two states are scrutinizing Devumi and its competitors online, where numerous websites sell fake followers or engagement on Twitter, LinkedIn, YouTube, Instagram and other social media platforms. [6] Its business practices were detailed in a New York Times article on Saturday describing a vast trade in fake followers and fraudulent engagement on Twitter and other social media sites, often using personal information taken from real users. [6] If Twitter is built on bots, how much stock should news outlets put in the social network? On the other hand, if outlets can?t control who follows them, does this even matter? It does if you expand the scope beyond fake followers and look at the real value, or lack there off, of Twitter?s relationship with journalism. [7] Like on Twitter, people pay for these fake followers to boost their numbers. [8] Officials at Twitter acknowledged that easy access to fake followers, and the company?s slowness in responding to the problem, had devalued the influence accumulated by legitimate users, sowing suspicion around those who quickly attained a broad following. [3] Twitter officials believe that the new policy will disrupt the marketplace for fake followers and curb abusive practices used to create fake accounts: Since suspicious accounts will now be stripped from users? followers, the company hopes there will be less incentive to purchase fakes in the first place. [3]

The Times revealed that one company, Devumi, sold over 200 million Twitter followers, drawing on an estimated stock of at least 3.5 million automated accounts, each sold many times over. [3] According to the Times, Devumi stockpiled at least 3.5 million automated accounts, repeatedly sold each one many times over, and provided customers with more than 200 million Twitter followers. [4]

The people losing followers include an array of entertainers, entrepreneurs, athletes and media figures, many of whom bought Twitter followers or artificial engagement from a company called Devumi. [6] The Times investigation focused on Devumi, an up-to-now obscure American company which sells Twitter followers and retweets to celebrities, businesses and anyone who wants to appear more popular or exert influence online. [4] As of January 2017, Ireland had only roughly 160,000 Twitter followers, but after an employee made several purchases from Devumi, her numbers jumped to more than a million. [4] Ireland boasts more than one million Twitter followers and often uses the platform to promote companies – such as Wisconsin-based American Family Insurance – with whom she has endorsement deals. [4]

You could use a service like Twitter Audit to run an analysis of a feed and find fake followers. [8] More than a million followers have disappeared from the accounts of dozens of prominent Twitter users in recent days as the company faces growing criticism over the proliferation of fake accounts and scrutiny from federal and state inquiries into the shadowy firms that sell fake followers. [6]

Ian Bogost is a professor of media studies at Georgia Tech, and he wrote a piece for The Atlantic questioning how much we value Twitter followers in general. [8]

Instead I went through and added the number of fake followers and real followers from twitteraudit and found the percent error from the number of followers on Twitter as a bit of a quality check. [9] Inspired by the absolutley beautiful bar graph /u/travgyse made of the number of twitter followers per team, I have gone ahead and added the percentage of “Fake” followers as suggested by /u/OutlawsHeels and /u/Last_Account_Ever. [9] Concerns over ID theft and fake Twitter followers lead to New York State probe As many as 15% of active Twitter accounts could be bots — and some bots are made using real biographical details from real people. [10] According to Twitter Audit, Rahul has the highest percentage of fake Twitter followers at 67 percent, followed by Shah, Congress leader Shashi Tharoor and PM Modi. [11] I think based on this criteria I?m a fake Twitter follower. [9]

In PM Modi’s case, Twitter Audit claimed 61 percent of his followers are fake. [11] Fake followers, as well as dormant followers (those who never tweet), can damage your account and eventually your Twitter presence. [12] By cracking down on fake accounts, Twitter hopes to restore faith in the controversy-ridden platform where influence–from entertainment to politics–can be inflated by automated or fake followers, the New York Times reports. [13] According to a statement given to IANS, Twitter said the “Twitter Audit” fake follower measurement tool is not the company’s product. [11] A recent “Twitter Audit” report claimed that PM Modi, Gandhi, BJP President Amit Shah, and others lead the list of leaders with fake followers globally. [11]

From former President Barack Obama to Justin Bieber, the internet’s biggest social media influencers lost millions of Twitter followers Thursday as the platform began a massive purge of suspicious accounts. [13] Hollywood stars, athletes and social-media influencers want to increase the number of Twitter followers they have and how many “likes” and retweets their posts receive. [10] The state of New York is opening an investigation into Devumi, a company that sells Twitter followers, likes and retweets to those looking to bolster their social media popularity, Attorney General Eric Schneiderman said via Twitter on Saturday. [10] Those who bought Twitter followers from Devumi include a wide range of well-known people, according to the Times, and include Dell Technologies CEO Michael Dell, former model turned businesswoman Kathy Ireland, Colorado Avalanche defenseman Erik Johnson, singer Clay Aiken, 1980s Brat Pack star Andrew McCartney, and Shark Tank judge Lori Greiner. [10]

There are useful tools out there that you can use to audit your Twitter account and get the numbers on fake followers. [12] It?s not out of the ordinary for popular Twitter accounts to have fake followers including bots –accounts created with the sole purpose of increasing a user?s following. [14] After reports surfaced that some of the top Indian politicians including Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Congress Party President Rahul Gandhi’s Twitter accounts are infested with fake followers, the micro-blogging platform on Wednesday termed such reports as baseless. [11] Any ideas on what should constitute a fake follower? I can make a program to do what twitter audit does, but I can’t think of any better way to classify a follower as fake. [9]

The Chicago Sun-Times ?s long-standing film critic was one of many named in a Times piece exploring ” the follower factory “: a bustling marketplace of fake Twitter followers called Devumi, whose clients, the Times alleged, include many notable figures in sports, media, entertainment, and beyond like Ray Lewis and John Leguizamo. [15] Brands don’t want fake Twitter followers; they want real, authentic, targeted followers with a genuine interest who can potentially be converted to leads. [16] “Devumi is one of perhaps hundreds of a cottage industry of websites that sell Facebook likes, Twitter followers and so forth,” said David Elliot Berman, a doctoral candidate at the University of Pennsylvania?s Annenberg School of Communication, who has also been studying the issue of fake followers. [17]

Not only do they show fake accounts, but they also show you what percent of your followers have had interactions on Twitter within the past 100 days. [18]

Does it matter that the context here is a social media environment known for bots, fake names, mysterious handles and a general lack of transparency? After all, an online auditing tool found that, at last check in late 2016, 14 percent of my followers were fake, and I have no idea how or why the fakes got there, honest. [19] Many of the Devumi accounts have since begun to disappear from Twitter, and on Wednesday, The Hill –employer of columnist Joe Concha, who was also named in the Times report–announced a new policy forbidding staff members from purchasing fake followers. [15]

The piece specifically targeted Devumi, a company that peddles Twitter followers and retweets to “anyone who wants to appear more popular or exert influence online.” [20] It takes a sample of 5,000 Twitter followers and assesses them on the number of tweets, followers, mutual followers and other parameters. [11] You can use Audiense to analyze your Twitter followers and find those that haven?t been active in a while. [12] Devumi’s website says it will sell anywhere from 500 to 250,000 Twitter followers, starting at $12. [10]

If that segment of the American people is actually made up of inactive, fake, or innocuous accounts, Trump clearly reaches a far smaller audience of the American public than a casual look at his follower count on Twitter would suggest. [21] In what is being widely mis-characterized as a purge of fake users, earlier this week Twitter started removing “locked” accounts from the follower counts belonging to active user. [22] Twitter has strict rules against accounts buying or artificially inflating the number of followers, retweets or other actions to create “fake engagement.” [21] Twitter did not respond to a request for comment by the Daily Dot about the company?s rules for someone else encouraging fake engagements or followers for a separate account or specifically about increases in sign-ups around Trump’s candidacy announcement or election. [21] While it’s unclear why so many of Trump’s followers are fake or inactive, it is clear that claims of him being able to speak to large swaths of the American public through his Twitter profile are incorrect, judging by just how exaggerated his following on the social media platform really is. [21]

Fake followers and engagement are against the policies of social media platforms (e.g. Instagram, Facebook, Twitter). [23] While Twitter is a hotbed of bot activity, fake followers and influencers on Instagram may be a much greater issue, defrauding advertisers up to $100 million a year. [23] Social media users, advertisers and regulators were aghast this past week over revelations in a report by The New York Times of a thriving cottage industry that creates fake followers on Twitter, Facebook or other channels for anybody willing to pay for them. [17] Although Twitter and Facebook officially frown on users buying followers and regularly take down fake accounts, they have a vested interest in the popularity scores of their users because advertisers use those metrics. [17]

The New York Times recently published an expose focusing on Twitter fake followers and the current investigation of the company peddling followers, Devumi. [23] Roeper became the first to have an employer publicly respond to the fake follower allegations, with the Sun-Times announcing that it wouldn?t publish any of his work until the newspaper finished an “investigation” into his Twitter following. [15] According to Hosanagar, Twitter, Facebook and others need to do more to curb the practice of fake followers. [17]

By the network?s own admission, Twitter follower counts are poor indicators of the actual number of people who follow a given account. [15] “Drawing on an estimated stock of at least 3.5 million automated accounts, each sold many times over, has provided customers with more than 200 million Twitter followers,” the newspaper?s investigation found. [17] “After nine years of working hard to go from zero to more than 21.5 million clients, I can assure you that the best way to use social media, and in particular, to grow your Twitter followers, is to be a filter. [16] “Another creative way to get more real Twitter followers is for a company to write an expert roundup, requesting interviews from 10+ experts in their field. [16] Besides taking a page from the world’s most creative marketers, you can get more real and engaged Twitter followers by installing our Twitter follow button. [16] Here are a few creative, actionable tips to get more real Twitter followers. [16] An investigative report from The New York Times exposed famous people who have purchased Twitter followers. [19] Due to the existing level of rapport with the company, this strategy helps to boost Twitter followers, as well.” [16] This is a great way to expose their own Twitter handle to the experts’ own Twitter followers, thereby gaining more followers of their own.” [16]

Some users boost the number of followers on the platform, and other services fed by Twitter, with either automated or fake accounts. [24] Caption Twitter is removing fake accounts from follower numbers. [24] It?s no secret that Trump?s Twitter following is flooded with fake accounts, but new insights into @realDonaldTrump ?s Twitter following show just how heavily the president?s social media presence is propped up by a fake foundation of questionable followers. [21]

There are several websites he mentions, with their pricing: “How much does it cost to fake popularity? On the cheap side, you can buy 1,000 Twitter followers for $14 on a site called InterTwitter; 5,000 followers cost $43; 100,000 cost $487. [25] Some of these accounts, as both Twitter and the tech site Scrunch note, actually buy these fake followers to make their Twitter personas (or personae ) look more important. [26] Over night the number of followers of his new Twitter account increased to a whopping 26,000! It got interesting when he analysed the results and looked at the Twitter accounts that these fake accounts followed. [27]

The leading social media companies are recognizing the dangers of fake followers and are creating new ways to check them. [17] It makes good business sense to do this, because fake followers on an individual account distort the influence ratings for advertisers, meaning that accounts full of fakes are a money-losing proposition for Twitter’s real, paying customers. [26] Twitter auditors make checking whether you have fake followers quick and easy. [28] Twitter announced it would be culling the platform’s fake followers. [26]

As a brand, we are using the tool of Phlanx Influencer Auditor to check if there’s fake followers of the influencer we wanted to work. [28] Some tools will check the number of inactive followers, as well as the fake followers. [28] Here are a few online tools to help you check for fake followers. [28]

According to the Fake Follower Check tool from StatusPeople, which claims the ability to determine how many of a user?s Twitter followers are fakes, 71% of Lady Gaga?s over 35 million followers are fake or inactive, along with 70% of President Obama?s nearly 30 million followers. [29] Even if the followers are fake, the clout that comes with a high Twitter following is very much real. [29] When it comes to removing fake, ghost, or “bot followers from Twitter, the process isn?t straightforward. [30] On services like Instagram and Twitter, if a person is following more people than how many followers are following them by a large percentage, it is often a clear sign of a fake account. [31] Devumi, a company that sells at least 3.5 million fake Twitter accounts as followers to anyone trying to “exert influence online,” has sold to people like former Baltimore Ravens star Ray Lewis, a reporter at Breitbart, and even a board member at Twitter, Martha Lane Fox. [32] A New York Times investigation revealed that an approximate 48 million Twitter users are fake profiles “designed to simulate real people,” which can be sold to customers trying to gain more followers. [32]

Buy Cheap Fake Twitter Followers: You can buy cheap Twitter followers, but the most economical Twitter services provide only fake bot followers. [29]

These facts are right but there are some reasons due to which people buy Twitter followers or other social followers. [27] You should also make a post where you could tell people about the pros of buying twitter followers. [27] Trump?s Twitter followers tweet more about the Kardashians than politics, data shows Trump’s followers like: pumpkin spice lattes and Taylor Swift, not so much DACA and Charlottesville. [21] This isn’t always the case, but some even more evil Twitter Follower services ask to access your Twitter account to send out multiple messages advertising their way of increasing people’s followers. [27] I know the 10% follower/follow ratio is such a headache though to deal with in the beginning of a new twitter account, and I would only buy Twitter followers for this reason. [27] Nearly 14 million of Trump’s Twitter followers are fake–and that’s just the beginning. [21] If you really want to boost your Twitter followers quickly, theres a better, more honest way to do it. [25] ManageFlitter allows you to manage your Twitter followers and community in a very powerful way. [27] It’s very reasonably priced (from $12 per month) and it’s going to help you grow your Twitter followers very effectively. [27] He started with the example of the ‘Fake Follower Check’ site, which shows how many Twitter followers aren’t real people. [25]

The move comes in the wake of a January Times investigation into a follower farm, which Twitter executives say inspired the company to crack down on fake accounts. [33] Another important thing you need to find out is whether your followers are fake or not ( 9-15% of Twitter accounts are bots ). [34] According to Twitter Audit, 32 percent of Lewis? 718,000-plus Twitter followers, or about 217,000 total, are fake. [35] All the fake Twitter followers in the world won?t do much to raise your Klout score. [29] Buy Real Twitter Followers: If fake doesn?t float your boat, buying real Twitter followers is a preferred option, although it isn?t likely to be as cheap as buying fake followers. [29] Your fake followers could also end up doing damage against your real Twitter followers by hacking, phishing, and infecting real followers with link spam. [29]

We’ve got all the tips and tricks on how to get rid of fake followers on Instagram and Twitter below. [30] We?ve discovered an efficient way for fashion bloggers and influencers to clear out fake followers (a.k.a. “bots and “ghost” followers) from their Instagram and Twitter accounts. [30] There are so many reasons why a fashion blogger or influencer would choose to buy fake followers for, say, their Instagram or Twitter accounts not that it’s okay. [30]

These days most people are aware that many Twitter accounts pad their follower lists with fake followers. [36]

Buying Twitter followers cheap gets you faceless, bland bot accounts – these are referred to as generated followers. [29] Those who give themselves a pat on the back when their newest instagram post gets 13 likes must certainly be temped by the idea of buying more Twitter followers. [29] Start-ups, celebrities, and politicians alike have been known to buy more Twitter followers – it?s a fairly common practice for those who have something to gain from amassing a large number of Twitter followers in a short period of time. [29] There are a number of dangers associated with buying Twitter followers. [29] The number of followers is a really good measure of the influence of your Twitter followers. [34] Among those who have turned to Devumi, an American company that sells Twitter followers and retweets to “anyone who wants to appear more popular or exert influence online,” is former Ravens linebacker Ray Lewis. [35] The best sites to buy Twitter followers from are those that provide targeted Twitter followers that are real and active. [29] If you?ve decided to take the moral high ground and not buy Twitter followers, don?t despair about missing out – there are plenty of ways to get Twitter followers naturally. [29] With a simple swipe of a credit card, you can obtain legions of your own mindless Twitter drones! To buy or not to buy? Let?s review the reasons for and against buying Twitter followers. [29] You?re not really buying Twitter followers so much as mindless spam bots. [29] While purchasing bot Twitter followers is against Twitter?s terms and white-hatters might scoff at the idea, it?s completely legal. [29] Pricier services provide Twitter followers with more finely polished profiles, with pics and bios filled out. [29] Hashtags : While you don?t want your tweets to be a messy glob of ###s, implementing some hashtags now and then makes your tweets easier to find and can help spread your scope while gaining Twitter followers. [29] If your Twitter followers start going missing on Thursday, it probably wasn’t because of a bad tweet. [33] If you?re set on buying Twitter followers, here are some sites that sell them. [29] Getting those followers isn?t always easy though, which leads some innocent businesses to wander down the shady path towards the ominous castle black-hat, wherein lies the dark tactic of buying Twitter followers. [29] There are a couple different approaches you can take for buying Twitter followers. [29] This process is referred to as buying targeted Twitter followers. [29] Buying Twitter followers may provide some temporary sense of instant gratification, but the potential backlash of being found out as a liar or fraud can quickly undo any advantages and permanently destroy your reputation. [29] You can use Crowdbabble to speed up and simplify the Twitter follower validation process. [36] You could put in all that effort? or you can grab your wallet and buy a militia-sized army of Twitter followers for less than a Starbucks Frappuccino. [29]

With tools like the Fake Follower Check tool, it?s pretty easy to discover who is desperate enough to buy friends. [29]

POSSIBLY USEFUL

Twitter puts a limit on the number of accounts a user can follow until he or she has more followers. [1] Devumi, the main company unmasked in the Times feature, is but one of dozens of businesses that sell followers, likes, and shares on social-network services like Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, and Instagram. [5]

Services like TwitterAudit, which can scan accounts for questionable followers and report a ratio of fakes, might become more widely used. [5] A user who has 171 followers and who is following 5,001 people is usually fake. [1]

Perhaps a new market might emerge, for those wealthy, proud, or arrogant enough to pursue extrication from the oppressive, numerical rat race: For a hefty fee, Twitter could forgo the display of followers, retweets, and all other numerical measures from a selected account. [5] That?s why Twitter counts followers, likes, retweets, and all the rest so prominently. [5]

For $5, he added 4,000 bots to his account, more than doubling his follower count at the time (he?s up to 18,000 today). [5] The Pro service takes a deeper look at your account and lets you block followers, as well as make your account private. [2] You will be able to mark a follower as “not fake”, which will still improve your score, once that follower is manually reviewed. [2] Many of our new followers were fake, created for the purposes of spam or resale. [5] “Even though I knew this was 100 percent fake, the thrill excited me,” Lotan writes, “and at the end of the process, having over 6,000 followers, in all honesty, felt really great.” [5]

To take away the followers I won in the Twitter-onboarding lottery would feel like a loss or theft, even though some large number of them are not real and never were. [5] The Times acknowledges the reasons why people and businesses might be tempted to buy followers. [5] This score is based on number of tweets, date of the last tweet, and ratio of followers to friends. [2] The plans are designed for Twitter users with different numbers of followers. [2] Pricing is solely based on the number of followers you have. [2] A user who inflates his or her follower count can leverage outsize impact on the outside world. [1] Of course, this scoring method is not perfect but it is a good way to tell if someone with lots of followers is likely to have increased their follower count by inorganic, fraudulent, or dishonest means. [2] TwitterAudit finds “low-quality” followers in the sense that they may be either bots, troll-types, or simply inactive. [2] How many of your followers are real? Your browser is ancient! Upgrade to a different browser or install Google Chrome Frame to experience this site. [2] It also takes for granted that “real” followers are valid and valuable. [5] To boast that one?s followers are all “real,” or to call for a near future in which that state of affairs is insured, is just to affirm the virtue of the system. [5] The New York Times claimed that Roeper and others such as actor John Leguizamo, motivational speaker Eric Kaplan and British baking star Paul Hollywood purchased followers from a website called Devumi, which charges a mere $50 for 5,000 followers. [1] Richard Roeper, film critic for the Chicago Sun-Times, was suspended on Tuesday for buying 25,000 followers after a New York Times investigation revealed the practice was widespread. [1]

The ideal follower might become an audience for an account?s ideas, influence, products, and services. [5] Blocking followers cannot be reversed, meaning if you unblock someone they will not follow you back automatically. [2]

Spotting fake Twitter uses is generally fairly easy, though fakers have gotten better at it over time. [1] The Times cites social-media influencers, a class of people–some household names and some unknowns–who can earn money directly from promoting products and services on networks like Twitter and Instagram. [5] It?s hard to imagine such a change taking place while companies like Twitter rely on the aspiration of visible metrics as a compulsion to use their services. [5] Many boring, ordinary desk jobs now often require some kind of social-media activity, and demonstrating personal credibility on platforms like Twitter is one way to lay claim to it. [5] The investor Mark Cuban called for a real-name policy on services like Twitter, arguing that “there needs to be a single human behind every individual account.” [5]

It?s easier to do this with a third-party tool, as Twitter doesn?t list these counts on users? following pages. [1] Cuban?s reform does square with the Times ? take on virtue and wickedness at Twitter. [5] The report exposes Twitter as willfully duplicitous to users, advertisers, and investors–revelations that could (and should) harm the company?s value and reputation. [5] In 2017, Twitter started reducing the visibility of such users. [5]

A colleague of Foddy?s at New York University, passed over by Twitter for such largesse, had become so agitated that he?d cornered Foddy to ask if he was buying followers. [5] Bennett Foddy and I were excited about our relative Twitter fame partly because of narcissism, and partly because it promised an improved platform for us as creators. [5]

In the aftermath of the Times expos the real influence of fake influence will likely decay, to some extent. [5] We use these scores to determine whether any given user is real or fake. [2]

Keep in mind that no algorithm is perfect and as a result real followers may sometimes be mis-identified as fake. [2] The Times contrasts the celebrities and the hucksters who service them with the innocent, ordinary folks whose profiles are sometimes impersonated to create fake followers. [5] The effect of fake followers often remains indistinguishable from supposedly real ones. [5]

We?d both been added to a list of accounts that are recommended to new Twitter users during the sign-up process, he explained. [5] TwitterAudit is the most popular tool, widely used and trusted by over 1 million Twitter users. [2]

While Twitter declined to provide an exact number of affected users, the company said it would strip tens of millions of questionable accounts from users? followers. [3] Twitter plans to start removing questionable accounts from users’ follower numbers on Thursday, reducing the total follower count on the platform by about 6 percent. [3] Twitter will begin removing tens of millions of suspicious accounts from users? followers on Thursday, signaling a major new effort to restore trust on the popular but embattled platform. [3] After The Times?s investigation was published in January, Twitter removed over a million accounts from the followers of Devumi customers — accounts that the company said violated its spam policies. [3] Until now, even after Twitter privately identified an account as suspicious and locked it, that account would still be included among the legitimate followers of a user. [3] Other well-known users have taken to Twitter in recent days to complain of lost followers, suggesting that a broad swath of people may be affected, not just Devumi customers. [6] “People assume when they have a follower on Twitter, that it’s not just a real human being,” Bogost said. [8] Dozens of websites openly sell followers and engagement on Twitter, as well as on YouTube, Instagram and other platforms. [3]

They offer useful analytics about other public accounts on Instagram, and also provide a cleanup tool to remove any of your followers that might’ve been flagged as fake or dormant. [37] If an account gets a bulk amount of followers overnight or in a day, it is most likely fake. [38] While Devumi promises customers “100 Percent Active, English Followers,” virtually all of the followers and retweets the company provides are fake, The Times found. [6] If an Influencer is a Sydney-based food blogger and a significant portion of their followers are based in Asia? then you could assume they have been purchased and are fake. [39] If the tweets have no response or a response not par with the following, followers are probably fake. [38] Of course, if the feed is empty or deprived of good content and still that someone has lots of followers, chances are those followers are fake. [38]

In the last few years, it has become popular practice for some people to buy bots to increase their followers on social media accounts — in January 2018, The New York Times published ” The Follower Factory,” to highlight this shady tactic. [37] This makes it look like they are getting higher levels of engagement through trying to game the social algorithms to rank them higher in feeds. This one is a tricky one as some accounts justify this activity by saying that they are just trying to get a head start to appear to more of their followers. [39] As they rationalize, “If the resulting ratio for likes and comments based on the number of follower is outside the industry standard, it is likely that the account has paid Instagram followers”. [37] The expanded reach helps play the algorithm of these services, which show content to the followers of the churn victims because there’s an assumption the content one account likes will also be enjoyed by that account’s followers. [40] Celebrities with millions get paid to endorse products on their Twitter feeds. For a journalist, Lambert said having at least 100,000 followers or more could help land a book deal. [8] If the followers are real, they?ll obviously want to interact with the Twitter profile. [38] While it?s against Twitter?s rules to buy followers, Twitter hasn?t even punished most users who bought thousands of followers. (Why would they? Twitter is desperate to keep celebrities using the site.) [41] Robots are on Twitter, and people pay to have them as followers. [8] The move would reduce the total combined follower count on Twitter by about 6 percent — a substantial drop. [3]

The locked accounts were nevertheless allowed to inflate the follower counts of a large swath of users. [3] Maybe a minute, a day or a week later, the churning account will unfollow that wave of people they just followed, absorbing the gains on their follower count. [40] There are some ways to sort through a feed to determine whether a follower is a real account or not. [8] Consider them a bot if they follow thousands of accounts, but only have a few followers in return. [37] The singer Clay Aiken, the actor John Leguizamo and the reality TV star Lisa Rinna have each lost a substantial number of followers, according to a review of their accounts. [6] For Influencer accounts that have organic growth, there tends to be a fairly consistent trend line of follower growth. [39] Built by a former NASA Scientist, the tool randomly scans 200 followers — based on those followers, it gives the Instagram account a score out of 100. [37] The return on paying a few cents per phony follower surely outweighs the ROI of advertising your account on each platform in hopes of luring followers. [40] Then for $5-30 (depending on your follower count) they?ll identify each account, and let you block some or all of them. [41] Check if the account has tons of followers, but terrible content. [37] That doesn’t necessarily mean these followers will engage with the content shared by the churning account, but it’s a surprisingly successful strategy typically employed by accounts without much original content. [40]

The key is to understand as a brand where you want to target? Do you only ship your product to one particular country? Or are you a physical retailer who needs to attract customers living in one particular location? If the Influencer?s followers are outside this, then fake or not, you shouldn?t be investing in them. [39] If they have none here – it?s a sign their followers may be fake. [38]

In recent months, Twitter has taken a number of steps to improve what Ms. Harvey and other company officials call “healthy conversation” on the platform, including rooting out fake and automated accounts. [3] The fake (Twitter) accounts are counterfeit coins in the booming economy of online influence. [4]

On Twitter, the sheer laziness in setting up the account makes bots easier to detect, but there are millions of legitimate users on the service who don’t tweet and just follow people they like. [40]

They?re not backed by human actors, but neither are a large number of Twitter accounts that have been abandoned but still get counted. [5] Most of the time, according to Twitter, the locked accounts are not included in the monthly active user count it reports to investors each quarter, a critical Wall Street metric for social media companies. [3] The disclosure of dozens of Devumi’s customers in entertainment, politics and business has sparked a renewed debate — often carried out on Twitter itself — about the prevalence of fraud and fakery on social media, where tens of millions of fake users still roam. [6] If significant amounts of those users are fake, that undermines the credibility of both the news organization touting the numbers and Twitter itself.” [7]

Entrepreneur and tech investor Mark Cuban says it?s time for Twitter to require that accounts be associated with a real person and for Facebook to tighten its requirements. [4] Cuban told the Times in a follow-up email that automated accounts, or bots, and impersonation on Twitter had made him “less enthusiastic about using the platform.” [4]

Twitter has since deleted about a million erroneous accounts, but some estimate the social network is haunted by nearly 50 million more. [7] Along with other social networks, Twitter was a critical tool for Russian influence during the 2016 election, when tens of thousands of accounts were used to spread propaganda and disinformation. [3] Both Twitter and Facebook verify the identity of some celebrities, politicians and other high-profile users and include blue check marks on their account pages, in part to prevent scam artists from impersonating them. [6] Twitter locks an account — blocking it from posting or interacting with other users — when the company suspects that it is automated spam, or that it has been compromised, usually by having its password hacked or leaked. [3] Mr. Cuban elaborated over email, saying that automated accounts, or bots, and impersonation on Twitter had made him less enthusiastic about using the platform. [6] Before he even graduated, his Twitter details were copied onto a bot account. [4] The Washington Post reported last week that Twitter suspended more than 70 million accounts in May and June. [3]

Engagement rate is simply the average number of engagements an influencer gets per post, divided by the number of followers. [39] On the flip-side, real, loyal followers take the time to make a comment about the image an influencer has created and share their own thoughts. [39] There is a cottage industry of social media mavens — or wannabes who have Googled something like “how to get a lot of Instagram followers fast” — who use a purely legitimate, albeit time-consuming, game of gaining followers. [40] These bots are used to do things like automatically retweet posts and inflate people?s follower count. [8] The number of followers may help determine who hires high profile people and how much they are paid for bookings or endorsements. [4] As news outlets and journalists built social media profiles, they began to judge their worth by their number of friends and followers. [7] Average number of engagements divided by number of followers. [39] You don’t want to pay an influencer if she uses a bot to collect followers. [37] Even for less famous but so-called “influencers,” followers can affect how much advertisers are willing to spend for their endorsements; that is the more people influencers reach, the more money they make. [4] Last month, the consumer goods giant Unilever, which spends billions of dollars a year on advertising, announced that it would no longer pay influencers who purchased followers and would prioritize spending advertising dollars on platforms that took steps to stamp out fraud. [3] “We don?t want to incentivize the purchase of followers and fake accounts to artificially inflate follower counts, because it?s not an accurate measure of someone?s influence on the platform or influence in the world,” said Del Harvey, Twitter?s vice president for trust and safety. [3] A bot might increase her follower count, but her audience probably isn’t truly engaged or authentic. [37] There is both social and financial pressure to have high follower counts, said Jennie Lambert, a social media consultant. [8] Federal and state authorities are investigating the sellers of artificial followers and other fraudulent social media engagement. [6] Again, though, a jacked follower count is easy to suspect without corresponding engagement. [40] Trust your judgment — if your influencer has 10,000 followers but only uploads below-average posts, her followers might not be legitimate. [37] These platforms are reluctant to tell organic followers which posts are paid for and which haven’t been promoted. [40] If you purchase followers that aren’t also required to engage with your posts in some way, then it’s pretty easy for a competitor or detractor to sense something’s up. [40] The average cost of getting a follower through each social platform’s advertising arm can range from $0.10 to $2 each. [40] The Chicago Sun-Times briefly suspended film critic Richard Roeper last month, for buying approximately 50,000 followers on at least six occasions from a company called Duvemi. [7] Bogost said we are not being critical enough about what it means to have a follower, whether that follower is “real” or “fake.” [8] Unless you?ve been selling your tweets to advertisers or putting your follower count on your rum no one cares. [41] There are whisper campaigns, I’m sure, about plenty of abnormalities in that follower-engagement ratio, but taking the step of publicly accusing someone of dishonestly padding their follower count is a big one. [40] Showcasing follower engagement isn’t as important, at least in theory. [40] If a significant portion of an Influencer?s engagement is coming from outside their followers, it is likely that they are signed up to an engagement app or engagement pod. [39] They get paid to do a sponsored post — which probably isn’t labeled properly — and they profit off of faking out their followers and stealing other people’s stuff. [40] Media-coverage site Poynter points to some more tools for cleaning up your follower list and auditing other users? followers. [41] “Does that follower, who may not even read the story they tweet, even pay a dime to support the news organization?” Convey asked. [7] You’re spending a lot just to get the followers, and then you’re going to have to reach them. [40]

They’ll follow thousands of accounts per day, up to the max allowed on Instagram and Twitter, hoping that the person behind the account in question is so thrilled by the follow that they’ll follow back. [40] Twitter does not require that accounts be associated with a real person. [6] Media, most often legacy media, rules many Twitter conversations, which gives it the leverage to pressure the network to combat its phony accounts. [7] Last month, Twitter announced that as of May, its systems were “locking” almost 10 million suspicious accounts per week, far more than last year, and removing more for violating anti-spam policies. [3] Akbar Gbajabiamila, the host of the show “American Ninja Warrior” and even a Twitter board member, Martha Lane Fox, had some Devumi accounts as well. [4] Twitter has also begun to permanently remove more suspicious accounts. [3]

The revelation of fake social media accounts has led some to call for tighter restrictions and more accountability from social media companies to ensure that real people are actually utilizing the services and reposting the comments of others. [4] As if that form of identity theft isn?t bad enough, fake social media accounts can also be used by hackers to install Trojan malware onto the networks of target organizations, according to a recent article in CNET magazine. [4] When the scheme failed to obtain the expected results, the hackers tried again, this time utilizing a fake social media profile that had been interacting with some of the targets. [4] The fake profile had over 500 connections on LinkedIn and an even larger number on Facebook. [4] Buying fake profiles to boost your influence ultimately hurts your credibility and will cost you business if you are perceived as less than trustworthy. [4]

Companies that trade in fake followers are hiring staff to upkeep these accounts so they look just like a regular account. [39] Fortunately, there are some quick and easy methods to determine whether an account has fake followers on Instagram. [37] These are just tips to help identify an account with possible fake followers, in some situations, some of these might not work. [38] Many factors needs to be taken into account to find if an account has fake followers. [38] New York Times reporting confirms something a lot of skeptical people have intuitively known for a long time: Hundreds of thousands of people — if not a number reaching into the millions — have purchased fake followers. [40] Bogost said he wishes the current furor over fake followers would make people realize that we are reading too much into the number of followers someone has or the likes a post receives. [8] Remember, fake followers can’t become real customers, so it’s critical you find influencers who can connect your business with the right people. [37] Once you’ve collected a list of potential influencers for your next Instagram marketing campaign, take a look at some of our tips and tools for detecting fake followers or bots, so you can ensure you’re only working with the best. [37] An investigation by The New York Times in January demonstrated that just one small Florida company sold fake followers and other social media engagement to hundreds of thousands of users around the world, including politicians, models, actors and authors. [3] To deflect attention, buyers of fake followers often also buy fake engagement in the form of likes and retweets and shares. [40]

As mentioned, it’s almost impossible to catch someone in a dishonest act like buying followers and engagement, but there are signs that could make you wary of working with an account or brand. [40]

True Twitter engagement usually takes time and builds up like a wave, not happening all at once. [40] Sudden floods of likes and retweets on Twitter just seconds after an otherwise mundane tweet is shared is a telltale sign of false engagement. [40] Ren LaForme, the digital tools reporter at the Poynter Institute for Media Studies, likes to think of the Twitter metric in comparison to tracking TV ratings. [7] Twitter usage and its influence should decline when more people go straight to media websites for their news. [7]

A Twitter spokeswoman says the company did not typically suspend users suspected of buying bots, partially because it is difficult for them to know who is responsible for any given purchase. [4] Though it is a smaller company with far fewer users than Facebook or Google, Twitter has been sharply criticized for allowing abuse and hate speech to flourish on its platform. [3] People liking a newspaper on Facebook or following it on Twitter is not going to float the boat.” [7] Mark Cuban, a prominent technology investor, tweeted on Monday that it was time for Twitter to change that policy, and for Facebook to tighten its requirements. [6] “If someone questions me on Twitter and I write back and there is an exchange in these bites of 240 characters, it starts taking up a lot of time,” he added. [7]

In recent months, advertising and marketing firms have put pressure on Twitter, YouTube and other platforms to help ensure that influencers have the reach they claim. [3] Twitter is not alone when it comes to fake accounts and bots. [8] A Twitter spokeswoman on Tuesday declined to comment about whether the company was purging fake accounts. [6]

According to the service Twitter Audit, 17 million of the New York Times? 41 million are fake. [7] In interviews this week, Twitter executives said that The Times?s reporting pushed them to look more closely at steps the company could take to clamp down on the market for fakes, which is fueled in part by the growing political and commercial value of a widely followed Twitter account. [3]

With bots and fake engagement, a lot of comments these days show up as very generic statements. [39] This is particularly important to identify fake engagement. [39]

It then becomes a fake indication of how the influencer is likely to perform. [39] Named “Mia Ash,” the profile purported to be a young woman working as a photographer in London, however, the persona was completely fake and used the Instagram photos of a young Eastern European woman. [4] They certainly won?t punish you for getting a few accidental fake follows. [41] They’ve bought fake traffic to pad their podcast download and listen counts. [40] About 11% of Breitbart?s nearly one million followers and 17% of the New Republic?s 160,000 are fake. [7] Of course, one of the common defenses for people accused of buying fake followers is that they didn’t buy the followers but the followers came to them. [40] All sorts of people have been found to buy fake followers: actors, athletes, even academics. [8]

If an influencer has very low engagement with their audience (sub 1%) then it is likely that they have some amount of fake followers. [39] There are some easy and not so easy ways to tell if an Influencer has fake followers. [39] Last month, the Times struck deeper at Twitter?s integrity with a story about the practice of buying fake followers. [7] In the world of Influencer Marketing fake followers and fake engagement is a problem that brands shouldn?t have to pay for. [39]

FakeCheck.co analyzes Instagram accounts by collecting data regarding the account followers’ engagement level. [37]

U.S. President Donald Trump has 47.9 million followers on Twitter. [7] They usually have alpha-numeric handles on Twitter, often with an Anglo-Saxon name and a bunch of letters and/or numbers after that. [40] As long as Trump–and Bernie Sanders, Marco Rubio, Pope Francis, and other leaders–use Twitter to debate policy, journalists will continue to spend a ton of time on the network. [7] “To many writers, Twitter can feel like an echo chamber,” LaForme said. [7] “When real political discussions, important discussions are happening on Twitter, journalists need to be there to take part,” Bilton said. [7] Twitter will brief staff members of the Senate and House intelligence committees on Thursday for their investigation into Russian operations to influence the 2016 presidential election. [6] “Impersonation and deception are illegal under New York law,” Schneiderman wrote on Twitter. [4] The Times found evidence that the information of Twitter users in every state — including thousands of people in Florida and New York — had been copied onto bots sold by Devumi or rival companies. [6] Millions of Twitter users are actually fraudulent bots, sold to real Twitter users, including many celebrities and media personalities, to inflate their stats and make them look more influential. [41] At least 55,000 fake accounts use the names, profile pictures, hometowns and other personal details of real Twitter users, including minors, according to a Times data analysis. [6]

Every now and then social networking platforms, like Instagram, identify and delete these fake accounts. [39] “We continue to fight hard to tackle any malicious automation on our platform as well as false or spam accounts,” spokeswoman Kristin Binns said, adding that it?s difficult to know whether the fake accounts cited by the Times violated the company?s policies against impersonation. [4] The fake accounts are “Counterfeit coins in the booming economy of online influence, reaching into virtually any industry where a mass audience – or the illusion of it – can be monetized,” The Times reports. [4]

Most of fake followers dont have Avi?s or profile pictures. [38] Even if you didn?t buy fake followers, some may have followed you. [41] Follower location is important to find out, not only to determine fake followers, but also to understand what portion of an Influencer?s followers are likely to be interested in your brand or product. [39] If you really want to, you can identify and block all your fake followers at TwitterAudit. [41]

An influencer with 100,000 followers might earn an average of $2,000 for a promotional tweet, while one with a million followers might earn $20,000, according to Captiv8, a company that connects influencers to brands. [4] You don’t want to use an influencer who doesn’t have real followers or a fully engaged audience. [37] It takes time, lot of hard work and tweeting to gain real followers. [38]

Included in the many examples of people buying followers are a writer for The Hill, a contributor to Breitbart, and editor at China?s state-run news agency. [7]

On its website, Twitter said it doesn’t allow “the purchasing and selling of account interactions” and warns that followers, likes or retweets bought are “often” bots or hacked accounts. [10] Twitter also has a bot problem, meaning that a percentage of your followers may be accounts operated by software and programmed to follow other accounts based on certain hashtags or keywords. [12] The more followers you have and the more influential you are on Twitter, you?re going to be targeted by more fake/bot accounts. [12]

Accounts that have followers/fans that have few to 0 followers themselves are another way to detect fake engagement. [42] A scroll through his followers shows that almost every other account lacks a profile picture, a possible sign that they are fake. [14] You have to regularly audit your followers to a) remove fake and inactive accounts that could damage your account and b) identify your most engaged and/or influential followers and interact with them more. [12] Some websites allow you to buy 1,000 followers for as low as $5 and fake influencers can easily trick brands into believing their audience is real (as shown in this study by MediaKix ). [43] Fake influencers can be spotted on three levels: through their profile, their follower?s profiles, and their follower?s followers. [42] When a high % of followers have hidden or private profiles, it can be indicative of a fake following. [42] President Donald Trump has said his social media following helped him land in the Oval Office, but a new report claims that almost half of his followers could be fake. [14] Rather than paying $5 for two reaudits I just took the ratio of fake to total followers and extrapolated that ratio to the present number of followers. [9]

Twitter said it expects the initiative to reduce the total follower count on the platform by a significant 6%, the Times reports. [13] If a higher percentage of your followers are active and engage with your updates, you’ll get rewarded by Twitter. [12]

“This specific update is focused on followers because it is one of the most visible features on our service and often associated with account credibility,” Vijaya Gadde, Twitter’s legal, policy, and trust and safety lead, wrote in a blog post. [13] Trump is not shy about promoting his social media account or boasting about his number of followers. [14] If the influencer didn?t buy likes and comments from bots, he would expose a very low engagement rate (number of likes and comments compared to the number of followers). [43] One of the common practices to grow your number of followers is to engage (follow, like, comment) lots of people and expect some of them to follow you back. [43] An account with lots of followers that have no posts or profile photos is suspicious. [42] A great way to get new followers who are most likely to be interested in the type of content you share is to analyze your competitors? accounts or, more precisely, their followers. [12] Their system is not perfect, but it will give you a general idea of how many of your followers are fake. [12] Sometimes, even a smooth curve can describe a fake audience: if someone with 5k followers is gaining 1k followers a day, you have reasons to get suspicious. [43]

Some federal and state lawmakers have called for more stringent laws regulating social media companies, in part to combat the epidemic of fake accounts. [6] They are fake accounts that have been set up with the intention of selling their ability to follow someone else?s account. [39] One such victim, a teenager named Jessica Rychly, had her account information — including her profile photo, biographical information and location — copied and pasted onto a fake account that retweeted cryptocurrency advertisements and graphic pornography. [3] Among other things, the fake account promoted various pornographic accounts and a gambling website. [4] The fake account remained dormant until last year when it suddenly began retweeting Devumi customers continuously. [4]

A recent New York Times investigation delved into how companies create and sell fabricated Twitter accounts, or bots. [8] I use a twitter management tool which provides a variety of these features that are essential to better manage your twitter account. [38]

The agency itself declined to comment but Marcus Holmlund, who managed the company?s social media efforts, told the Times he started making monthly purchases from Devumi after a supervisor told him to buy followers when the numbers weren?t growing fast enough. [44] A New York Times investigation published Saturday found that a number of those celebrities buy at least a portion of their social media followers. [44]

A good-looking influencer profile has followers, but also engagement in the form of likes and comments. [43] Even the celebrity or influencer might be unaware that many of their followers are bots, unless they actively block fake accounts. [20] The more followers you have, the more fake accounts will follow you. [9] Inactive followers or those who never interact with your updates are not necessarily fake accounts, but they still have little value to you. [12]

Famous people on social media–actors, models, athletes, influencers–like to brag about the size of their follower count. [44] “People who judge by how many likes or how many followers, it?s not a healthy thing,” he added. [44] What the heckfire? 400,000 followers expunged! At a stroke? Nearly half a million of my devoted adherents were BOTS? It explains so much. [13] According to its website, “the scoring method is not perfect but it is a good way to tell if someone with lots of followers is likely to have increased their follower count by inorganic, fraudulent, or dishonest means”. [11] At Upfluence, our Influencer software analyzes each profiles data (as well as their followers, and follower’s followers) to determine whether an Influencer is genuine before including them in the database. [42] Greiner?s lawyer told the Times she told Pallen not to buy any more followers after she became aware of the purchase. [44] “It?s fraud,” Cracknell told the Times, explaining that he regretted purchasing 50,000 followers. [44] Kaplan, who is a friend of Donald Trump, denied purchasing followers when he head from the Times, which found eight orders connected to his personal email address. [44] Blau told the Times someone on his management team bought 50,000 followers and thousands of retweets without his permission. [44] “Countless public figures, companies, music acts, etc. purchase followers,” Leal told the Times. [44] Many brands grapple with the issue of valuing an influencer’s true reach, using the number of followers as a main gauge. [20] It will have false positives. but I think it’s pretty clear that some schools are paying extra to juice their follower numbers. [9] “Our followers look like any other followers and are always delivered naturally. [44] The never-ending desire for more followers, retweets and likes can be addicting, Levinson said. [10] To use your Twitter account for maximum impact, you want to have a relevant audience with a high percentage of followers who regularly engage with your content. [12] In some cases, having many followers entices others to also follow those Twitter accounts. [10] Journalist Yashar Ali ran a Twitter audit on Trump in January and found that 68 percent of the president?s followers were real. [14]

The problem of fake influencers is present across all major networks ( Instagram, Twitter, Facebook ) and growing in many influencer marketplaces. [42] According to Twitter Audit?s analysis, cited by the Baltimore Sun on Monday, about 32 percent of Lewis?s Twitter following is fake. [44]

Here are two accounts that were following a fake Instagram influencer. [42]

“We only use promotion techniques that are Twitter approved so your account is never at risk of getting suspended or penalized,” the Times quotes Devumi?s website as saying. [44] I have had an account on twitter forever but I have like 100 posts since the beginning. [9] It’s still unclear whether platforms like Twitter and Facebook are responsible for weeding out the fake accounts. [20] Instagram, YouTube, Facebook and Twitter are full of influencers and new ones are popping every day. [43]

Women have more followers and create more engament on Instagram. [43] Those who can pay the most for followers can buy their way to apparent influence.” [10] The employee didn?t have Ireland?s permission to buy followers and was suspended, according to a spokesman. [44] Pallen initially denied doing so, but later admitted that he had experimented with buying Devumi followers but had stopped. [44] AgoraPulse helps me keep track of my influential followers and makes it easy for me to further engage them since I can reply without leaving the tool. [12] Phil Pallen, a brand strategist, purchased followers for some of his clients, including tens of thousands for Greiner starting in 2014. [44]

Hollywood also denied purchasing fake followers, telling the Times, “Account does not exist,” when reached for comment. [44] The firm’s founder, German Calas. told the Times that it didn’t sell fake followers and he said he had no knowledge of media identities stolen from real users. [10] Following lots of people doesn?t mean that the influencer has fake followers (it may be a good way to start and get people’s attention) and it can be a legit way to get your first followers but it might also indicate that the content?s value was not the only reason why people followed him in the first place. [43]

“Fake influencers? are social media profiles that commit fraud by faking high engagement and community size in order to participate in influencer campaigns. [42] Any of the above is a red flag that the account may be fake. [12] TwitterAudit determines whether a user is fake or not based on a set of criteria, including the number of tweets, date of the last tweet, followers/friends ratio. [12] I probably followed 50 or so Twitter accounts in the couple weeks I used it, and had a handful of friends following me, but i never tweeted anything so my account probably counts as fake. [9] Even fake twitter users don’t want to follow Wichita State. [9]

The tool basically allows you to automatically identify any influencers who are following you on Twitter. [12] In October, Twitter said it had 330 million monthly active users. [10] Create a Twitter list and add the most engaged users you found with Twitonomy. [12]

It advertises: “Bring your Twitter to life with automatic retweets and likes on all of your tweets. [10] It also offers Twitter likes and retweet plans priced as low as $9. [10]

Those numbers are also used as a barometer of how popular individuals are on Twitter — and the more admired they are, the more money they can get paid for say, new movies or endorsement deals. [10] Since the election, he has defended his use of Twitter by claiming it help him beat out Clinton in 2016. [14] Tricking Twitter into thinking a bot is not a bot is part of it, he added. [10] Katy Perry, the most followed person on Twitter, lost at least 1.5 million followers, leaving her leaving her at 107 million followers, Variety reports. [13] Notice that they exhibit suspicious follower / activity ratios and have their profiles on private? When you request to follow either, Instagram will actually block the action with a message stating that they are protecting their community! We can conclude that these are in fact, fake followers, bought to boost the community size of a fake influencer. [42] Nvm, looks like the methodology for finding fake followers includes people who haven?t tweeted in a while. [9] It is extremely easy to buy your way to success by purchasing fake followers, likes and comments. [43] Unlike fake followers and fake likes, fake comments are easy to detect: they are all generic. [43] An employee at the branding agency Sterling/Winters was responsible for purchasing fake followers for Ireland, whose follower count increased from about 160,000 to more than 1.1 million in the span of a year. [44] In comparison, the website says former presidential candidate Hillary Clinton has 9 million real followers and 10 million fake followers. [14]

Why are so many fake people following UVA? I thought we were boring. [9] How can a brand separate influencer fact from fiction? We reached out to Danica Kombol, CEO of Everywhere Agency, an influencer marketing firm that works with Fortune 500 companies, for some tips on spotting influencers with fake followings. [20] As fake influencers and bot networks become more sophisticated, technology will be crucial for combating fraud in Influencer Marketing. [42] As influencer marketing increases in popularity, the ability to spot fake influencers has become critical to the continued success and credibility of the market. [42]

I don’t think any school would be fake accounts either, but as another commenter noted, shill bots try to look real by following a bunch of accounts. [9] The New York Times recently published an exposon the practice of buying followers, a sizable number of which are bots that either steal a real person’s identity or use a random string of letters and numbers as a username. [20] Duke’s real followers should be broken up into “alumni”, “bandwagon” fans, and ESPN accounts. [9] These fake followers, or “bots” often form entire networks of fake profiles. [42] Bottom: Another fake account interacting with the fake follower from the first account. [42] There’s really no way to be 100% sure whether someone has fake followers, none or a mix of fake and legit ones. [43] Trump?s fake followers have increased since the 2016 election, but so has his follower count. [14] The New York Times named several other individuals it found to have purchased fake followers at some point or had fake followers purchased on their behalves by an employee, family member or someone else. [44] His personal assistant Ashley Knight denied purchasing fake followers, despite the fact that her email address was associated with a purchase of a quarter of a million followers. [44]

The Times estimates that up to 48 million of Twitter?s users–nearly 15%–fall into the category of fake accounts. [20] This can be explained by the social network deleting fake accounts. [43] This is the latest kind of fake account we detect, as bots are getting more and more sophisticated. [42] Top right: a presumably fake account that engaged with the influencer’s post. [42]

It’s probably a lot of people like me who made a Twitter account six years ago, followed a few sports accounts, and never signed on again. [9] This tool is quite straightforward and easy to use since it?s built specifically for unfollowing Twitter users who haven?t been active for a period of time. [12]

Twitter announced on Wednesday that “locked” accounts would no longer count toward people’s follower numbers. [45] Starting on Wednesday, Twitter will remove all locked accounts from people?s follower numbers. [46]

Evaluate an influencer’s followers and look for private accounts, accounts without a profile photo, accounts that follow thousands of users but maintain only a few followers, nonsensical usernames, and accounts with a low number of posts. [23] Aside from influencers like Beyonce ( @beyonce ) who maintain millions of followers and follow no accounts, authentic influencers typically follow 1-5% of their total following size. [23] He would open the follower list of a Twitter influencer in his own niche and paste the code to follow them. [16] If you can follow 2,000 people, then you will soon get at least 600 followers for your Twitter profile. [16] When people feel that your Twitter feed contains genuine content, they?re more likely to stick around or help to boost your follower count through organic reach.” [16] You can use it to look at follower growth and engagement data for YouTube, Instagram, Twitter, and Twitch. [47] “Another great Twitter campaign that earned millions of new followers was Amnesty International?s #GayTurtle campaign, in which the organization made a video of customers shopping for a turtle, filming their reactions when they were told one of the turtles was gay. [16] Take this example with a plastic surgeon client: We went from promoting in-office specials on Twitter with 100 followers to an entirely revamped strategy where we found industry KOLs and only tweeted educational, FACTUAL content. [16] Twitter chats not only show your expertise and gain new followers, but chats can also bring in new business and help you network further.” [16] “Although I haven’t used the Twitter chats tactic regularly, the first two techniques got me 3,000 followers in just five weeks with a mere five minutes of work each day.” [16] In the case of Twitter, this leads to a ton of new followers for us, as well as sales. [16] Just about every conversation I?ve had in the past week has come around to the question of how we should regard those who purchase followers on Twitter. [19]

If you want to protect yourself from investing in a fake influencer, you?ll need to have a keen eye to spot inflated followers, engagement, and traffic stats. [47] An engagement rate that?s either unusually high or low in relation to an influencer?s total followers and/or industry norms may indicate that an influencer has bought fake engagement. [23]

He pointed to a 2014 video expose by the website Veritasium on buying fake Facebook followers. [17]

“People having an artificially-inflated follower count made up of bots and redundant accounts is at best deceiving and at worst, fraud. [46] The metrics are shifting a little bit away from number of followers or number of likes to real engagements that are harder to automate, though we can certainly expect that the bots are going to catch up and find ways to do that.” [17] Influencers may try to increase their follower count by following a large number of users at once, waiting for those users to follow them back, and then unfollowing said users. [23] In addition to examining an influencers followers, examine the accounts an influencer follows. [23] “This light-hearted and fun-loving approach cultivated a network of followers who appreciated the way that the brand openly mocked other overly-promotional accounts. [16] This process may also help to capture an older demographic that may be less technologically savvy than other groups, giving them a way to punch in a website and start following. (Editor’s note: Be sure to place social media follow buttons prominently on your website to capture potential followers who are visiting your website, rather than your social media profiles directly.)” [16]

She recalled “a big purge” of fake accounts a few years ago on Instagram, which caused follower numbers to drop sharply for some users and angered them, even in cases where they hadn?t bought those bots. [17] Now that you have the tools you need to rid yourself of fake accounts and spammers, purge these deadweights from your network and start the new year fresh on social media with real and engaged followers. [18] “If the metric were “how many of the followers are valuable for me,? then social media platforms would have had an incentive to take fake accounts off their platforms. [17]

“In response, the emphasis shifted to engagement – how many of your followers actually like, comment on or share your social media posts. [17] Unfortunately, people can purchase likes and engagement in addition to followers. [47] “A lot of people don?t want the bots to go away if it means their followers and likes decrease.” [17] Because many users reflexively follow people back, the result is a quick surge in followers. (You can often–but not always–spot a practitioner if their robust following sits alongside a mark showing that they follow 5,000-plus accounts.) [15] The consistent loss or “bleed” of many followers is atypical of genuine accounts. [23] The number of posts (photos and videos) on an influencer?s Instagram profile should relate logically to their follower count; more posts should equal more followers. [23] An influencer may have faked their followers and engagement if they?re consistently gaining a small number of followers while simultaneously losing a large number of followers. [23] The following tips are meant to help marketers gain a better sense of whether an influencer has paid for engagement or followers, but these guidelines are not intended to be foolproof or conclusive. [23] A social media user?s engagement rate should be somewhat proportional to their number of followers. [47]

While the New York Times exposshed light on the magnitude of the problem, the practice of buying followers has been around nearly as long as social media itself. [20] Basketball star Shaquille O’Neal also lost about a million from his 15.3 million followers, and Oprah lost about 1.4 million followers, the Times reports. [13] According to the site, only 43% of Lady Gaga?s 76.5 million followers are real, as are 67% of President Trump?s 47 million followers. [20]

As many as 15% of active Twitter accounts could be bots — and some bots are made using real biographical details from real people. [10] Between 9% to 15% of active Twitter accounts are bots, according to a study by the University of Southern California and the University of Indiana, published in March. [10]

Twitter Audit is an external tool not affiliated to the micro-blogging website. [11]

One thing you can check is the profiles of those who liked or commented the influencer?s content. [43]

To audit your Instagram followers, make sure to check out Social Audit Pro. [18] The best time to post on Instagram by day, niche, and more You put tons of work into creating amazing Instagram posts and images to capture the attention of your followers (and get more of them), but even the. [16] ” in practice, most of these followers did not engage with the social media posts of brands and so-called influencers,” Hosanagar continued. [17] Refinements in how social media companies measure the numbers of their followers might help, Ron Berman suggested. [17] Does the paper correspondingly think that follower numbers should dictate other things–like pay, maybe? If the goal is to pay writers by the traffic they generate, there are much better metrics (like, uh, actual traffic). [15] Now, however, bots have evolved to become more sophisticated with convincing photos, followers, likes, engagement. [23] Evaluating engagement rates (total # of likes + comments / total followers) is one way to gain a baseline understanding of how reactive an influencer?s audience is. [23] Being known as a good source of information on a specific topic, subject, or industry is the best way to increase your follower list and maintain a healthy following while improving the amount of engagement you get from your followers. [16] Be wary of influencers that maintain a large “following” base in comparison to followers, as this may indicate they have bought followers or used bulk follow-unfollow methods. [23] Is the influence of a paid follower different than the influence of a paid blogger? When a brand buys a lot of borrowers, is it different than advertising? These questions have to be carefully answered, and the platforms do not yet have answers.” [17] “Also, liking a ton of posts and commenting on them increases your post’s engagement, which can generate brand awareness and some new followers, as well. [16] Just take a close look at their followers and keep an eye out for red flags like followers with no photos or posts. [47] How to get 500 real, targeted followers on Facebook fast Welcome to the Facebook Marketing Strategy series in which we share the best practices for how to use Facebook for business! This is part 13 of the s. [16] “Follower counts are a visible feature, and we want everyone to have confidence that the numbers are meaningful and accurate,” Gadde said. [46] “Measuring the value of online followers is quite hard, so people resort to using simple metrics such as follower counts,” he said. [17] “One of the best ways to increase your followers is to provide useful information that people who are interested in your business or sector may find useful in their own capacity. [16] “Those who can pay the most for followers can buy their way to apparent influence.” [17] There are a number of ways to conduct manual fake follower and engagement audits on Instagram influencer accounts. [23] Depending on the sophistication of a fake follower service, bots, and the influencers purchasing them, paid-for engagement Instagram accounts can be incredibly convincing. [23]

“We are more influenced by the people we know, people who are in our social circles, and these fake active accounts may simply not matter to many users for that reason.” [17] “Our digital ecosystem is being polluted by a growing number of fake user accounts, so Twitter?s commitment to cleaning up the digital space should be welcomed wholeheartedly by everyone, from users of the platforms, to creators and advertisers,” he said. [46] Facebook or Twitter may find such services at conflict with their attempts to go after fake user pages, she said. [17] “Facebook has a disincentive to identify and shut down some of those fake “liking? accounts because, ultimately, those accounts liking your content dilutes it getting out to the real audience. [17] Companies or individuals create fake Instagram accounts to sell (and resell) their follows, likes, and comments. [23] At the end of 2014, Instagram attempted to systematically rid its platform of fake or bot accounts. [23]

If you have too many low-quality accounts that are either fake or never online, the initial engagement rate your posts will be low. [18]

Twitter locks accounts when it detects “sudden changes in account behaviour” – for example, if the account tweets a large volume of unsolicited replies or mentions; if the account posts misleading links; or if a large number of other accounts block the account in question. [46] Twitter is the social media platform where your cachet, your status as an important voice and influencer, is measured by the number of people who have chosen to follow you — to have your little thought-bursts and self-promotional wheezes show up in their timelines. [19]

Locked accounts are those that Twitter has frozen but not deleted because it has detected sudden changes in user behaviour. [45] Twitter said locked accounts tend to have been created by real people, rather than bots. [45]

I ran a Twitter Audit Report of my 11,346 followers, of which the service reported that about 96 percent are the profiles of real people (<3 you, all my non-robot pals). [15] Remember that bots or inactive followers will never engage with your posts. [18] It?s actually pretty easy to spot bot followers without using any tools. [47] If a large portion of their followers has never tweeted, that?s another sign they could be bots. [47] If you notice any unnatural drops or spikes in followers, it could mean they?re paid or bots. [47] If you want more followers, whether they?re bots or politely reciprocal human strangers, you can go right out and get them. [15]

We measure our return on investment based on the number of new followers we receive, the number of impressions we receive, how much referral traffic we get, and of course – how many we generate as a result of the campaign.” [16] “Over time, you will realize that your followers bring other followers and that your role is to be an expert to provide them with the MOST valuable, most recent, and most relevant information in the SHORTEST time possible. [16] “Partner with another company and give each other shout-outs in their own feeds, encouraging their own followers to follow the other company. [16] The paper identified “entertainers, entrepreneurs, athletes and media figures,” who?ve bought followers by the tens of thousands, including critic Richard Roeper of the Sun-Times, who has been reinstated after a brief suspension. [19] Don’t use random (non-relevant) hashtags in your tweets, or they could be flagged as spam or may be distracting to followers who perceive your tweets as commercials.” [16] Get involved in conversations on their tweets to help their followers get to know you. [16] Hosanagar recalled that some eight to nine years ago, social media marketing was focused almost exclusively on acquiring more and more followers. [17] “Finally, I would recommend that you stay away from a schedule unless you?re covering an event or trying to market a competition or special offer, etc. Unless you?re giving your followers notifications, your content posts should only be made when you have something valuable to say or contribute. [16] Your posts won’t ever reach a broad audience even if you have lots of followers. [18] It?s important to remember that having fewer, more readily engaging followers is better than having lots of false or paid-for followers that are largely inactive, as this does little to increase the effectiveness of your posts regarding marketing ability. [16] Lots of brands and individuals spent money on acquiring followers, and marketing companies cropped up that offered to build one?s follower base, he said. [17] To get an overall picture of how your followers are interacting with your brand, consider taking a look at Fakefollowers. [18] Depending on the initial engagement level it gets with that initial sample group, it either dies off, if it performs poorly, or if it does well, the algorithm accelerates it by showing it to more followers and beyond. [18] If their engagement rate is suspiciously low, they could have inflated followers, or just a very disengaged audience. [47] If you blow your following to follower ratio out of proportion, it can be a turnoff for potential followers. [16] This is a great way to appeal to the other company’s audience and share followers between the two. [16] Ron Berman is surprised that the manipulation of follower counts is being described as a “new” discovery. [17] Some have hundreds or thousands of followers spread across multiple profiles. [17] Once the audit is finished, you can quickly remove the followers that the tool has given a low quality score to. [18]

“The best way we have noticed brands getting more real followers on Twitter is through social listening and keyword outreach. [16] Twitter can similarly look at followership from reputed or validated accounts as an indicator.” [17] Twitter says it locks an account if it detects sudden changes in behaviour, such as tweeting lots of unsolicited replies or mentions, posting misleading links, or being blocked by numerous accounts after mentioning them. [45] This isn’t the same as deletion, and Twitter often will unlock an account after a set period or once it has verified the account owner. [45] In both cases, Twitter contacts the owners of the account and asks them to validate the account and reset their password. [46] Twitter said these accounts were different from spam accounts, which typically exhibit spammy behaviour from the beginning and so are easier to identify. [46]

Called “bots,” these fake accounts are available in the thousands to those that want to boost their popularity with tweets or retweets on Twitter, or Facebook likes or shares. [17] If influencers–the Times cited the model Kathy Ireland, who uses Twitter to promote corporate endorsement deals and whose Twitter following was more than tripled last year using a bot service–are able to trick companies into thinking they have more sway than they do, that?s on those companies for not doing their due diligence. [15] Buying bots isn?t the only less-than-reputable method of inflating Twitter followings. [15]

Twitter gives live video precedence over other types of content, so we receive a high number of impressions that lead to a ton of real Twitter followers.” [16] The problem comes when other people–or other organizations–take those numbers, which even in the very best of times are flimsy and poor indicators of just about anything beyond “time invested on Twitter,” too seriously. [15]

Twitter is a platform like no other, where self-promotion isn’t welcome like Instagram and Facebook. [16] “You actually can go buy from some of the same companies hundreds or thousands of votes in online contests, and they exist obviously on platforms like Twitter and Facebook,” Golbeck said. [17] Companies like Facebook and Twitter typically try to work around these problems in three ways, “none of which is perfect,” said Yildirim. [17]

“Steak-umm approaches Twitter a lot like Shia LaBeouf approaches celebrity: with a series of self-aware stunts that simultaneously parody and celebrate the platform. [16] The campaign worked because Coke understood how to use a simple, but memorable hashtag married to a marketing method that gave its audience the power to personalize their Cokes and turn them from a product into something they were willing to share across not just Twitter, but other social media platforms as well. [16]

In one common tactic, a user deploys an automated tool to follow the daily Twitter maximum of 1,000 users –real ones–each day in the hope that those users will in turn follow them back. [15] “Twitter as well as Facebook can emphasize and give priority or weight original new content created by users, instead of promoting retweets and content shares,” he said. [17] If the detection algorithms at Facebook or Twitter find that some users are only liking certain pages that they are paid to promote, they would weed them out and close them down. [17] The creators of the bots try to stay a step ahead of a Facebook or Twitter that might attempt to identify them and take them down. [17]

“Follow even more: If you follow 100 people on Twitter, then at least 30 of them will follow you back as a sign of courtesy. [16] Some smart people have told me they believe there?s nothing shady about buying a little marketing edge on Twitter. [19] Our creative approach was a direct pivot in strategy from self-promotion to offering quality information to the people on Twitter. [16]

This is the best way to increase brand awareness and grow your Twitter following and sales using a ‘Tag You?re It’ Twitter contest/campaign.” [16] “The point here is that Twitter becomes the afterthought, and you?re doing a PR stunt to get eyes on your brand in the community in a fun and engaging way. [16] “Participating in Twitter chats is also a great way to get amazing branding and exposure for your company’s Twitter profile. [16] When you discover quality, relevant posts shared by others, recreate them with your own style from another perspective, or enrich them with newer information and tweet them from your Twitter profile. [16] “Another good way to increase the amount of attention your Twitter page generates is to reach out to others in your field or sector and respond to their posts or ask them questions. [16] For companies looking to duplicate this type of Twitter campaign, find a way to tell a story that takes us by surprise and relate that story to your product or service.” [16]

I have a question, I’m working in my followers on Instagram, if I follow and unfollow people, they are going to block my account? For me that is an organic way but I didn’t know that Twitter for example can give you a penalty for this. [27] There is nothing wrong with following or unfollowing a large number of people every now and again, but if Twitter think you are aggressively trying to increase your followers by follower/unfollower churn methods, you are likely to get your account suspended. [27] Zombie Account Following. (Facebook & Twitter) By paying a 3rd party you can get 100s, 1000s of even 10,000s of followers or likes. [27]

The social media platform is starting today to remove tens of millions of accounts that may be fake from follower counts, the New York Times reported. [24] The best article I review IG profiles for brands, and most are fake, they now DRIP FEED followers in a few hundred a day to just make it look legit, but then all the accounts are fake ones. [27] Since that time, popular news outlets like Elle, Forbes, Mashable, Newsweek, The Atlantic, as well as influencer marketing powerhouses like CLEVER and Sway Group, have jumped on the “fake” followers hot topic in an effort to expose and educate agencies and brands. [28] The fake number of followers then influence others when it comes to politics, business and entertainment, the Times reported. [24] Understand that all social networks are also always clearing out fake likes, followers and plays. [48]

If you visit its site and enter a Twitter handle, you can find out how many followers, tweets, RTs, etc, that particular account had over the past month. [22] I won’t say they are active followers but when you make a new account on Twitter, that initial boost makes you grow organically at later stage. [27] Aggressive Following Technique. (Twitter Only) By following a large number of people each day, waiting for them to follow you, then unfollow those who don’t follow you back it is possible to artificially increase your followers very quickly. [27] While the shock of numbers going down may hit users now, Twitter officials say that the adjustments to follower counts will level out as they continue to work on identifying and challenging “problematic accounts.” [24] While I do agree having a large number of followers looks good (and I’d be lying if I wasn’t proud by the fact that I’ve grown my following to over 50,000 on Twitter), there are other metrics that I feel are more useful and important. [27] While you might get a good follower number in the meantime, it could hurt your brand but more importantly, it is against the terms and conditions of Instagram and Twitter. [27] Unfollow irrelevant followers, and start to use Twitter lists to manage the people you really want to keep tabs with. [27] According to SocialRank, 25.5 percent–or 10.2 million Trump followers, as of Oct. 10–have yet to share any content on Twitter, and 18.9 million of his followers have not shared content in more than a year. [21]

When you factor in the number of accounts that have not tweeted in the past year–18.9 million, according to SocialRank–and the 27.1 million accounts that have not shared content in the past 90 days, the number of active and engaged followers of @realDonaldTrump plummets considerably. [21] Does the account follow a high number of people but have a low amount of followers? Wave that red flag. [28] Whether we like it or not, on one level, the number of followers an account has does matter, If the account has very few followers, it does usually create a negative impression. [27] What is the moral of this story? Well apart from it not being moral to buy your followers and having the possibility of having your account suspended or deleted, the number of followers you have really isn’t that important. [27] Social Audit Pro, HypeAuditor, and several others are paid services that provide follower analytics for Instagram accounts. [28] It is risky for your account and you can lose them at any time if Instagram bans those follower accounts. [27] You can?t pay money for followers on social media and then expect that those followers are committed to you or that there?s even a real person behind the account. [49]

Devumi?s founder, German Calas, denied that his company sold fake followers and said he knew nothing about social identities stolen from real users, The New York Times report noted. [17] Fake followers, and the influencers purchasing fake engagement hurt brands in a number of ways — namely, the newest form of ad fraud. [23]

Fake influencers are social media users or bloggers who trick brands into thinking they have a large, attentive audience, when they really don?t. [47] Fake users are just a number they aren’t going to engage with your brand or become paying customers. [16]

When vetting and selecting influencers on influencer marketing platforms, brands failed to tell the difference between real and fake Instagram influencers. [23] Last summer, global brands offered to pay for sponsored posts with two fake Instagram influencers that Mediakix created. [23] Facebook, who owns Instagram, has conducted similar purges removing hundreds of millions of fake likes from major publisher pages. [23] Mediakix recently did an experiment by creating their own fake Instagram influencer. [47] The rise of influencers has also given way to fake and fraudulent activity by some influencers. [23]

Fake profiles often spam legitimate users, posting inappropriate or illegal content. [17] University of Maryland’s Jennifer Golbeck and Penn’s David Elliot Berman discuss the impact of fake users on social media. [17] As such, marketers need to know how to properly vet and identify fake engagement and influencers or work with an experienced influencer marketing agency who can deliver results with proven social media influencers. [23] Pollution of social media networks through creation of fake profiles is becoming increasingly common. [17] Several signs can help you spot a social media fake who might be trying to scam your business.( How to Spot a Social Media Fake by Aksana Nikolai,Chron). [17]

Buy yourself a big, fake diamond and tell everyone it?s real, and later go home and giggle about how impressed everyone was. [15] They put minimal effort into the experiment and were surprised when several unsuspecting businesses offered paid work to the fake influencer. [47] Mediakix has done a bunch of work on fake influencers, how to spot them, and how to weather this. [23]

Mediakix created the accounts and only purchased fake followers in order to show how easily and cheaply this could be accomplished. [23] In the aftermath of our Instagram fake follower experiment, several platforms and tools presented solutions (e.g. algorithm or software-based services) for dealing with bots and bought engagement. [23] The number of fake followers, engagement, and influencers leveraging bots to boost their online presence has unfortunately grown in tandem with the influencer marketing industry?s success. [23] Aside from paying for imaginary likes, comments, and engagement that have no impact on ROI, fake followers and influencers hurt the influencer marketing industry as a whole by (1) diminishing its efficacy as an effective advertising channel and (2) tarnishing social media influencers? reputations. [23] If you’ve been on social media for more than a few years, it’s quite possible that you’ve accumulated a number of fake followers along the way without ever knowing about it. [18] Just like fake news, fake followers are a massive problem on social media. [18] Later that day, Schneiderman?s office launched an investigation into Devumi, a social media marketing services firm in Florida that The New York Times report highlighted as one of those behind the fake followers. [17] Fake followers will end up undermining the value of social media platforms, Wharton marketing professor Ron Berman predicted. [17] At present, we don?t believe a tool, platform, or algorithm exists that can accurately detect and vet fake followers and engagement. [23] As steady, consistent follower growth can be interpreted as organic growth, some fake follower tools mimic these growth patterns by consistently adding only a few followers at a time — a practice called “dripping followers.” [23] Not only can having a lot of fake followers damage your social credibility, it can hurt the distribution of your posts. [18] Potential influencers could be buying fake followers or using other strategies to grow their audience artificially. [47] In the time since the issue of fake followers has reverberated throughout the news. [23] Like various aspects of influencer marketing, spotting fake followers is nuanced and can be affected by a myriad of factors. [23] By using the methods presented in our fake follower guide, becoming more knowledgeable with the additional resources below, or working with a qualified influencer marketing agency, marketers can safeguard against fake followers, engagement, and influencers. [23] It?s difficult to believe that if Facebook is unable to adequately remedy its fake follower and engagement issues that companies of lesser resources and talent would be able to provide a viable solution. [23] “They were demanding that Instagram give back the fake followers because they wanted to look more popular, even though they knew they were fake.” [17]

“Those fake accounts are still active on Twitter,” she said. [17] I once unfollowed an editor whose following binges kept filling Tweetdeck; I promptly received an email from him–clearly, the follow-back generator was not the only reputational Twitter tool he was using–asking why. [15] It?s not nearly as silly as the Sun-Times thinking that Twitter followings mattered much in the first place. [15]

“Finding relevant news to share (we work with tech startups across the Southeastern U.S.), and in addition to crafting a message for Twitter that mentions specific users and relevant hashtags, I also upload an image or graphic. [16] Beautiful, quick to install, and easy to configure our Twitter follow button is designed to help you instantly grow your audience on Twitter. [16] In terms of Twitter, either the Fakers App or TwitterAudit will help with that. [18] “Business owners must first create a card to help promote the ‘Tag You?re It’ Twitter contest. [16]

They can then use the interviews to write an article and request the experts share it on their own Twitter pages, tagging the interviewer in the tweet. [16] “The biggest impact will probably be when journalists, who try to use Twitter as a source of information, will start being more sophisticated in verifying the validity of tweets. [17]

“First, Steak-umm created a social media campaign based on their experience of trying to get verified on Twitter, which was ultimately a self-fulfilling prophecy. [16] Dorsey and Twitter have been pushing a wider discussion about how to improve the “health” of conversations on Twitter, which has struggled to tackle abuse and harassment on its platform. [45] Smart Twitter profile: Your professional Twitter profile must be smart and attractive to grab attention at first glimpse. [16] Added Berman: “I would not rely on the beneficence of Facebook and Twitter to regulate themselves. [17] In a friendly tone, describe your passion, creativity, target or motto, and the service you provide in your Twitter bio. [16] Twitter is a place to establish yourself or your brand as an industry thought leader. [16]

It can be manifested in many ways, including bulk messages, profanity, insults, hate speech, malicious links, fraudulent reviews, fake friends, and personally identifiable information. [17] The damage could be worse if politicians and public figures make statements which do not find large support in public, “but because of fake accounts and bots look like they do,” she said [17] “These shadow economies doubled down on creating bots and fake accounts that would share or retweet their clients? posts. [17]

Buying engagement from fake accounts effectively boosts vanity metrics and gives the appearance of a well-followed and engaging account. [23] As the New York Times expose surfaced, fake accounts can sometimes be fabricated from and mimic real accounts. [23]

This tool will help you identify and remove all dormant or fake followers. [18] Great article, it provided us great insight and tools for fake followers. [23] Their failure to do so indicates that fake follower and influencer detection can be extremely elusive and beyond the scope of established influencer marketing platforms. [23]

For celebrity Twitter users with huge followings, like Katy Perry (110 million followers), Barack Obama (104 million) and Donald Trump (53 million), this could mean a sizeable culling of their follower counts. [45] A Twitter account with more than a million followers but only a few retweets per post looks pretty suspicious they?re probably buying followers. [47]

Other smart people have told me they believe buying followers constitutes an outright lie and one to be taken very seriously in an era when employers, readers and advertisers take notice of and sometimes rely on a person?s reach on social media. [19] David Berman said the practice of buying followers suits the business model of social media platforms. [17]

Don’t panic thinking you have to weed through hundreds or thousands of existing followers’ profiles to figure out who is real and who isn’t. [18]

“There was a post on Medium describing how Karan J. Thakkar used code to follow a huge number of Twitter users at once. [16] The rules are as follows: Follow our Twitter account, and DM us your unique card code for a contest entry. [16] Some estimates suggest that about 15 percent of all Twitter accounts –almost 48 million accounts–are automated. [15]

“Tweet quality content: Your tweets must be interesting and informative for the serious Twitter users in your niche. [16] Once you upload an image, you can tag up to 10 (relevant!) Twitter users by using the ‘Who?s in this photo?’ tool. [16]

The platforms didn?t flag the fake accounts for removal or alert brands of the spammy nature of these accounts. [23] Those techniques look at the activities of an account (languages used versus location of account, patterns in tweeting and followership, and many other factors) to detect fake accounts, he explained. [17] “Real people are located in a network of other real people and show a pattern of usage that is likely to differ from that of the fake account. [17]

In a January New York Times article entitled ” The Follower Factory,” it stated: “Celebrities, athletes, pundits and politicians have millions of fake followers.” [28] Does this sound familiar? Have you thought about doing this? Well you should understand it is not difficult to spot if someone has purchased fake likes, followers or plays. [48] More than half of her followers are fake – 53%! This from the woman who claims to be a consumer advocate? The person who stands up for the little guy? More obviously, she’s the person who said her ancestry was Native American to get those university posts through the affirmative action slot. [26] Forty percent of Harris’s followers are fake, well beyond a margin of error. [26] High plays and low followers is a red flag for fake purchases. [48] Now, with 1383 followers, 49%(!) turned out to be fake, 7% were Inactive, and 44% were good. [25]

According to Variety, some accounts lost millions of followers from their follower counts. [22] In the past the locked accounts remained in the follower counts, the company said. [24] You just checked your follower count on Twitter and it says you have 150 followers. [50] You could use Twitter Counter to track the followers they have (or the analytics tab in Manage Flitter). [27]

President Donald Trump and his administration have repeatedly bragged about the size of his following on social media, but Trump?s audience on Twitter –clearly his favorite method of communicating with the public–is inflated with even more fake or inactive accounts than previously believed. [21] It’s not clear why Trump’s Twitter following is bolstered by such an extreme amount of fake or inactive accounts. [21]

Data provided to the Daily Dot by SocialRank shows that more than 13 million “egg accounts,” users that have yet to set a profile photo and rarely tweet-a large indication of “bot” or fake followers-follow Trump, making approximately 33 percent of his following completely fake. [21] To be fair, Facebook came clean recently and claimed that over 83 million Facebook accounts are fake which confirmed what a lot of people were already thinking. [27]

Not only are Trump?s followers mostly inactive, but a staggering amount of accounts following the president were created after he announced his candidacy for president in June 2015, according to data compiled by Trump or False. [21] The tools can also identify the most suspicious followers and give you the option to block them if the account is your own. [28] This strategy is as simple as going to a website, paying them money, and then watching followers flood your account. [49] The one thing to watch out for are the accounts that go from having a couple hundred followers to thousands of followers almost overnight. [28] The analysis shows that 56.7 percent of Trump?s followers, as of Oct. 9, created their accounts after Trump announced he was running for president, and 37.7 percent of the accounts were created after he was elected in November 2016. [21] According to data from SocialRank, Trump’s 25 percent of inactive followers is significantly higher than other commonly followed accounts. [21] Every time I get like 4-5 new followers the number goes down by 20-30 followers. [27] Hi Andie, are you asking whether Instagram could block you for aggressively following and unfollowing people in order to build up a large number of followers? The answer is “possibly”, although you could get away with it. [27] We live in a world where some people will judge by the number of followers on social media. [28] And, we know full well that influencers are often paid based on the number of followers they have on social media. [28] A high number of followers can boost social proof in a superficial way. [27] The number of followers you have does help to a degree with social proof. [27] Buying some followers can help people to get more followers through all over the social networks. [27] When you buy followers and count on that to function as social proof, it?s not hard for real humans to tell that you don?t actually have committed followers. [49] To put it into the Influencer Marketing perspective, let?s say you like an influencer?s Instagram feed and notice that the person receives a lot of engagement on every post and also has a lot of followers. [28] The platforms do various levels of audits of a profile?s followers that can include analytics from followers to likes, engagement, and more. [28] Let’s make an effort not to play the numbers game and be impressed with the number of followers or likes some business has. [27] First of all, by tracking the number of followers they have over time. [27] The number of followers is such a superficial statistic, but yes, it does act as a form of social proof. [27] If you combine sharing high quality content with following the right kind of people who are likely to follow you back, you will definitely grow your followers. [27] You hope that more people will follow you because you now have so many followers. [49] People may not know that you’ve bought followers, but going from 30 followers or likes to 30,000 in the space of a couple of days is bound to get people suspicious, and then your integrity and reputation could well be in tatters. [27] It has many options to buy the followers with partial or semi-partial followers, likes from the targeted count. [27] Higher-end sites like Buy Active Fans promise not just followers, but engaged followers — and even American ones. [25] Any website that says, “Real Retweets & Followers” and then has a button to “Buy Followers” is outright lying. [49] Using a combination of humans and technology, our vetting process makes sure our clients are getting the biggest bang for their buck by working with influencers who are legit, honest, and backed by readers and followers who are real because we?re in the business of keeping it real. [28] Most of the time, influencers gain followers slow and steady over an extended period of time. [28] If an influencer posts content that goes viral, then the followers are almost guaranteed to increase. [28] I bought 5k Followers on Instagram but after few days these followers lost. then I try real strategies after reading your post now I have real and active followers. [27] Nowhere am I with 10k followers and half a dozen likes on each new post. [27]

After paying for followers/fans or engaging in aggressive follower churn, you are likely to get a large number of fake accounts amongst your number. [27] Similar technique, look at the number of plays and followers. [48] They’re not always going to say! It’s difficult to prove that people bought followers, although it can look pretty obvious. [27] When you buy followers or fans, you aren’t getting people who are interested or willing to engage with you. [27] Plus, the people you target after you buy the followers are what matter. [27] People can tell because those thousands of followers aren?t engaging with your content. [49] Although time-consuming, you need to spend some time reading through followers? feeds. Check out the content that the followers are posting. [28] Give me 100 super fans any time over than 10,000 spammy followers. [27] Clearly, growing your following the good, old-fashioned way is far more effective than buying your followers. [49] The way to handle unbalanced followers and engagement gets solved that way. [27] That causes a natural and suspicious discrepancy between your follower count and your engagement rate. [49] Because you definitely don?t want to violate the platforms’ policies, create a discrepancy between your follower count and engagement rate, hurt your business reputation, or destroy any data that you have. [49] SB is not 100% accurate – it has my current follower count wrong – but it’s still useful tool that you can use to quantify your losses. [22] If we didn?t use the human element, then we wouldn?t be absolutely certain that we were providing our clients with the best of the best when it comes to influencers and their followers. [28] In our FORWARD Influence database, we keep a track record of how many followers our influencers have. [28] Used gramcart for this experiment, they have likes, followers and auto-likes services with fairly good support. [27] With the regular methods, their follower growth looked like this. [49] Followers are even cheaper on FanMeNow, where you can buy 1,000 followers for $10 — or 1 million for $1,350. [25] There is no quick and easy way to boost your followers, unless you want to be a naughty boy and buy them. [27] Tools are only part of the story when it comes to growing followers, but I wanted to list some simple ways that can make the job easier. [27] Can you suggest me best Instagram tool that I could increase my followers. [27]

Building relationships with these people will expand your reach and help to grow your followers. [27] Are a lot of the comments in a wide variety of languages? Yes, we know that people know more than one language and people have followers from all over the world. [28] I want people to trust me and I want to build up an army of followers who engage with me and are interested in me. [27] Then I checked the ‘Fake Follower Check’ site again and re-ran the numbers. [25] It was easy to try and compare the number of followers I had with others in my field and get depressed. [27] Thank for article! Why and for what purposes need more followers everyone decides for himself! I think that in a small number of followers required for beginners. [27] Fees can range from one-time to prices based on the number of (alleged) followers. [28] Wow, really? That’s awful to lose work based on the number of followers you have. [27] Now, look at their results when they used a bot to build followers. [49] You could look at buying enough followers to break the 2,000 barrier, but I still would recommend against it. [27] Well, I suppose you could argue that buying a few thousand followers may not be so noticeable. [27]

I’ve now got over 50,000 followers, and that does give some element of social proof. [27] Organic followers, on the other hand, involve no risk and can actually pay you real money. [49] Most users lost a few followers, and a few of my friends lost hundreds or thousands. [22] I’m not sure most popular profiles buy followers, but I am going to assume many do. [27] Blogger, Zach Bussey, decided to do an experiment and create a new Twitter account and buy some followers. [27] The 100 most-followed Twitter accounts saw an average drop in followers of 2% on Thursday, according to social-analytics firm Keyhole, with a median decline of 734,000 followers. [22]

Trump is obviously a high-profile account on Twitter that often ends up on lists of “who to follow” for both new users of the social media platform and active users. [21] Generally each supplier has a database of twitter or Facebook “zombie” accounts that they can use to follow or like you. [27] Recently, Twitter has been locking about a million accounts a day, a Washington Post investigation uncovered. [24] Twitter certainly disallow “aggressive follow/unfollow churn”, and I do know people who have had their account suspended as a result of doing this. [27] While it’s possible that people signed up for Twitter to follow the president but quickly lost interest, the sheer number of fake accounts has Michael Cook, who compiled the Trump or False data, speculating that accounts are being intentionally created to increase the president’s social media presence. [21] Again, appears to be within the normal range of fakes, but note that this one also was updated recently, when the news broke of the Twitter culls, or perhaps after the cull happened. [26]

There are so many robotic Twitter and Instagram accounts out there that really offer very little value. [27] Singer Katy Perry, who has the most-followed account on Twitter, lost 2.8 million followers through Friday at 8 a.m. ET, dropping 2.6% to 106.8 million followers. [22]

Amid his much-criticized response to the violence stemming from a white supremacy rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, in August, Trump?s followers jumped from 35.3 million on Aug. 8 to 36.2 million on Aug. 18, a few days after receiving vehement criticism for his response. [21] You can buy services that will find followers that interested in your art or business. [27] The only reason I would buy followers is to avoid the headache and hassle of the 10% follower/follow rule. [27] I would say it’s safe to start off in the beginning with no more than 1,000 followers to buy. [27] That initial stage is really hard if you don’t buy followers- getting from zero to your first 500 or 1,000 followers. [27] Not everyone will have the same issues, and if so, please go ahead and buy followers. [27] You might be surprised to find out how many of your followers might be spammers or spam bots. [50] I work in fashion industry and now social media followers is vital to success. [27] Here are the engagement results using a regular method for building followers. [49] I really do need to write another article on how to grow your followers the right way. [27] They do as they promise, and your follower count will surge forward quickly. [49] Follower counts for Justin Bieber and Rihanna fell 2.5%, Ellen DeGeneres dropped 2.6%, Taylor Swift fell 2.7%, and Lady Gaga declined 3.2%. [22] For more tools and tips on how to grow your followers, come back soon. [27] You cannot share permanent links to your Tweets with anyone other than your approved followers. [50] If your tweets are worthwhile, youll have loyal followers in no time.” [25] Great for discovering high quality content that you can share with your followers. [27] Trump’s following also includes 13.7 million “egg accounts,” or inactive accounts with no profile pictures–a clear indication of a bot, or fake follower, Kharly Stauber, SocialRank?s head of content and accounts, told the Daily Dot. [21] If a platform deletes your account because you bought fake followers, then you definitely can?t build any kind of following. [49] You can use a tool such as Fake Followers in this post or again use ManageFlitter Power Mode (paid version) to return the followers of that account who have a spam rating over a certain amount. [27] I know that the landing page promised it would, and I know that they promised that no one would be able to tell the difference between real and fake followers on your account. [49] Now, it’s entirely possible that bots glom onto accounts without permission, adding some fake followers. [26] If an account has fake followers, it looks more influential than it really is. [26] With fake followers, you run the risk of having the powers that be delete your account. [49] My own personal account has 4% fake followers, and I don’t even know how to get rid of them. [26]

If you?re trying to fake that social proof and they find out, your real followers aren?t going to be happy. [49]

When you buy fake likes you will only get a large number and nothing else, nothing more, no future engagement. [48] If there is a large number of page likes but very little or no engagement it is a red flag that the page has purchased fake likes. [48]

At the end of August on the Facebook Security blog, Facebook announced they were going to remove fake likes from pages. [27] In November 2017, Facebook disclosed to investors that it had at least twice as many fake users as it previously estimated. [28]

While some are saying spam accounts, or bot accounts, or fake accounts, were purged, a better way to describe this is that Twitter purged the accounts that had been “locked” by Twitter for some rules violation. [22] Ryan Tracey commented on a post I wrote last year called ” Do you know the Twitter Limits ” to say that he was the victim of 24,000 fake accounts following him. [27] A real account on Twitter could be @iamarealaccount while the fake account could be @Iamarealaccount. [28]

These accounts were effectively dead, and thus no longer active, so Twitter removed those accounts. [22] Two different analyses shared with the Daily Dot show that more than a quarter of Trump?s Twitter following, as of early October, have never tweeted before–with one data set going further to show that nearly half of his following has been largely inactive on the social media platform, only tweeting five times or fewer. [21] Lot of different ways to grow twitter following, buying is just one of them. [27]

Some pay for services help you accomplish this since most of us do not have the extra time to give twitter the attention it deserves on a daily basis. [27] For instance numbers are almost everything with twitter since the average lifespan of a tweet is 18 minutes. [27] In addition to spammers, hackers and internet criminals may send out malicious Twitter bots to follow you. [50] It is pretty easy to get a idea of fake accounts on Twitter by using the website www.TwitterAudit.com. [48] Twitter have automated systems in place to detect automated behaviour like this. [27] The idea of Trump using his Twitter feed as a direct line of communication between the American people and the president has been trumpeted by both former White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer and, as recently as Tuesday afternoon, current White House Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders. [21] “The goal was always to allow people to make their own inferences from our data, and we would just keep it as factual as possible on our end,” Cook told the Daily Dot in a Twitter direct message. [21]

Agora Pulse integrates with Twitter, Facebook and Instagram. [27] You can quickly and easily go through all your Facebook, Twitter and Instagram mentions and comments and get down to inbox zero. [27]

I’ve come across a similar service for Instagram called Instagress, and I know there are similar facilities for Twitter. [27] Although I have mentioned Facebook, I have mainly being referring to Twitter throughout this post. [27] Social Blade is a social media analytics startup that (among other things) tracks Twitter activity. [22] The first few days nothing happened, and then about 50 normal twitter notifications (@name) is now following you on Twitter) flooded in on Sept 8th. [25] I decided to take the risk, as they needed my Twitter password for this. (Yeah, Ik now, I know. risky, but hey I did not use that password anywhere else, and I have changed it right after the order completed. [25] Spammers look for every possible avenue they can to inundate you with spam, this includes your twitter feed. [50] Just scroll down the list, do a few spot-checks here and there, and it becomes very clear which ones are real followers, and which ones were created by software and basically are twitter ghosts. [25] If you fill up your Twitter accounts in the first week, and buy (let’s say 2,000 followers) using a drip feed method to make it look more natural so that you get a faster follow back ratio in the beginning, what is so unethical about this? Sure, 2,000 people may not be interested in your content, but there are still ways to buy real followers. [27]

Our Account Management team stays on top of the trends and does manual checks on our members to make sure they are providing accurate numbers, as well as have accounts that contain real followers. [28] When an influencer shows interest in a campaign, our Account Management team visits their social media accounts to not only verify stats, but also to check the engagement and make sure nothing fishy is happening on their social media accounts. [28] What about if your a real customer and before buying from the business you decide to check out their social media accounts. [27] Be sure to check for duplicates and make sure you are working with the real accounts. [28]

The problem is that buying followers like that goes against Instagram’s terms and could jeopardise your account. [27] It?s our job, as an Influencer Marketing Network, to know our influencers and to ensure they are real people living real lives while using real social media accounts and engaging with real followers. [28] I’ve recently had a social media PR company start working for me, and I wanted to know how I could secretly find out if they are doing the whole ‘buying fake followers’ etc. [27] When you buy fake followers, it?s unlikely that those followers will benefit your business nearly as much as taking the time to build a genuine and organic following on social media. [49] Most of the times users know they are buying fake followers but they still do. [27] FakeCheck, FakeLikes, and similar tools scan Instagram profiles and determine the number of fake followers as opposed to real followers. [28] Well, guess what: there is an extraordinarily high number of Democrats, the kind who draw lots of media hype, with puffed up “it” status, loaded with fake followers. [26] Guess those millions of non-crumbs can pay for lots of fake followers, is that it? You’d think someone who’s at the head of her party and refusing to step down, despite the obvious need to, would have enough influence to not apparently have to buy fake followers to look important. [26] If you?re like most people who buy fake followers, then you?re not looking at it as an eternal, always-on kind of strategy. [49] Knowing the issues that have evolved and the pressures of the environment, we know, as an Influencer Marketing Network, that thoroughly vetting for fake followers will help us deliver an Influencer Marketing campaign that will reach the right people, get great engagement from real followers, and turn followers (and influencers) into lifelong fans of the campaign sponsors. [28] Hi Ian, I totally agree with you on this one, I rather have 100 real followers than 1000 fake ones. [27] If nothing else, the fake followers will create social proof and encourage other real people to follow you. [49] Harris, by contrast, has way, way more fake followers – 55% at the time I wrote this and now 40%. [26] Now you may ask with all the fake followers and no engagement how did I cope, you simply use auto-likes service. [27] The vast numbers of Democrats with fake followers suggest that their influence is not only not there, but not going to translate into votes. [26] The lefty showbiz Democrats, by contrast, have some spectacular numbers of fake followers – Rachel Maddow, Jimmy Kimmel, Jimmy Fallon, Bill Maher, Eminem – all clocked in huge numbers of shills. [26] It is an important point that not everyone who has a large number of fake followers has paid for them. [27] The last thing you want to do as an agency and/or brand is work with influencers who have fake followers. [28] We?ve been in the game for almost a decade and have put plans into place to help us avoid working with influencers who have fake followers. [28] Unfortunately, fake followers are not just found on one social media platform. [28] Because here?s the thing: social media sites don’t want you to have fake followers. [49] What’s worth looking at is the New York Times report, which noted that he lost 3 million fake followers, compared to President Trump, who lost 340,000 fake followers. [26] As I wrote here in discussing the shadowbanning of Ted Cruz, Cruz had 17% fake followers, a pretty low count compared to Harris, and the New York Times notes that President Trump has a small percentage. [26]

The harsh reality is that all of those fake followers you did or didn?t buy aren?t going to help you. [49]

Eventually those that buy fake get caught one way or another. [27] Though many people promise that the fake method will work, it won?t. [49] There’s quite a difference between 3 million fakes and 340,000 fakes – a tenfold difference, actually. [26] It will be all the more confusing if you spend the extra money for fake engagement. [49]

Dan Scavino Jr., the White House director of social media, and Sarah Huckabee Sanders, the White House press secretary, also did not respond to multiple requests for comment by the Daily Dot about the number of fake accounts following Trump or why the number of fake accounts is disproportionately high. [21] I got so many spammy comments, follows from fake accounts, and fake likes. [27] Do you have a basic understanding how fake likes even work? Purchasing fake likes wouldn?t give anyone a audience? they are FAKE accounts, not real people. [48]

When real people discover them, your fake followers do nothing but hurt your reputation rather than help it. [49] Unfortunately, though, using fake followers and fake engagement will automatically skew your marketing tests and results. [49] Once you delete your fake followers, you?ll be ready to start building an organic following that will actually pay you back without any of the risks. [49] They discourage using fake followers every step of the way. [49] At the end, I?ll show you how you can delete your fake followers if you?ve made the mistake of buying them in the first place. [49] At least, I can confidently say that it will be far more worthwhile than buying fake followers would be. [49] When it comes to buying fake followers, there are two primary methods. [49] The main point of this article is why buying fake followers is a bad idea. [27] Here are five specific reasons that you should never buy fake followers and, if you have already, why you should delete them immediately. [49] American Thinker, for example, has 2% fake followers, and no, we didn’t buy those. [26] The issue of fake followers is still an issue on Facebook, it is just a little more difficult to analyse. [27] Fake followers will not only confuse your results, but they will also confuse you about which content is performing well and which isn?t. [49] Those are just a few of the reasons why fake followers don?t go over well in Influencer Marketing. [28]

Stripped away of the egg accounts, Trump is left with roughly 27.5 million followers, a far cry from the 41.1 million he boasted as of Tuesday evening. [21] Why use humans when you can use a platform or a tool to help you vet influencers, especially when you?re working on a large-scale campaign that involves hundreds of influencers? At FORWARD Influence, we rely on a combination of tools plus humans to help us wade through the waters and make a big splash with influencers who have real followers. [28] Just follow each other? Maybe at least we can get a good number of all real followers who understand the urge to do so. [27]

Whether we like it or not, buying followers go against the terms of conditions of most social networks. [27] Whichever way you look at it, buying followers goes against the terms of the social networks and could get you banned. [27] You described all the cons of buying followers for any social media profile. [27] You gave so many great reasons why one should avoid buying followers but also nice tools to grow their fans and their engagement. [27] Buying followers from certain places will increase the number of followers greatly. [27] Well, the advantages of buying followers are that you can get a large number of followers fast. [27] No matter what people think, buying followers goes against Twitter’s terms and conditions AND it can hurt trust and integrity. [27] It’s a controversial topic and I know people will be on both sides of the fence (or even sitting on the fence) when it comes to buying followers. [27] I think there is no question that some people will benefit, at least in the short term, when buying followers. [27]

Of the 56.3 million followers of Kim Kardashian, 15.9 percent are entirely inactive; of the 102.4 million people following Justin Bieber, 16 percent are inactive. [21]

If it’s just faster and finds real followers like zen-promo.com? I say that because I bought followers on instagram but it’s fine as I think. [27] Using auto-like services or buying followers does three things firstly it goes against Instagram terms and conditions. [27] Well, buying followers is a quick way to boost the vanity statistics. [27] There is only one way of buying followers and it is via shoutouts. [27] Hi Christine, It really depends on the method the place you’re buying followers uses to add followers. [27] When you?re in the middle of a failing strategy, buying followers really starts to look appealing. [49]

You can then go through and quickly follow Twitter accounts that look promising. [27] Right after receiving that email I checked my Twitter account and sure enough, the number was correct. [25] You could use a tool such as ManageFlitter for this. 4) Find a selection of high quality, influential and relevant Twitter accounts in your niche. [27] If your Twitter account has been locked, you can follow these steps to get it reinstated. [24] With the power mode, I can follow the Twitter accounts that an influential and relevant person in my niche follows. [27]

When checking out an influencer?s Twitter account, for example, you?ll want to look at the followers/following ratio. [28]

It is fairly easy to find out the names of people who are being followed by fake accounts as I mentioned in the first point. [27] As you probably already know, most of these services function by creating a massive amount of fake accounts and then using them to follow their paying members. [49] Each shady website that wants your money in return for fake accounts has compelling sales copy. [49]

Theres a part where for some reason (this is the first time I watched one of his theories and they were as messy and cringey as I thought), Shane, Ryland and James Charles were looking at percentages of followers for accounts that are just bots (fake people). [51] Cleaner for IG is the best app for removing unwanted followers (real or fake) from your Instagram account. [30] Once you?ve determine which accounts are fake, block these “followers” from your account. [30]

Follower counts will continue to change as Twitter works to remove more bad accounts from the service. [52] President Donald Trump?s account lost 100,000 followers immediately after Twitter made the change, a Washington Post reporter found, and former President Barack Obama lost 400,000. [52] Twitter told the Times it plans to remove about 6 percent of the site’s total combined followers — a number that could be in the tens of millions. [33] You can use Crowdbabble’s Twitter reports to help assess whether your followers are real. [36] Through this report, you can easily find that Friday 2:00 PM is the time when most of Crayola’s followers are active on Twitter. [34] Most people will lose four followers or fewer because of the change, Twitter said. [52] “We?re introducing a change to follower counts as part of our work to make Twitter a more trusted service for public conversation.” [52] If Twitter does decide to clean up the spammers, it?ll be pretty embarrassing when your follower count drops by half. [29] It?s a heck of a lot easier to buy followers on Twitter than earn them. [29] Twitter “strictly prohibits” buying or selling interaction and followers. [32] The aim here is to unearth insights that will help you generate more followers, retweets, mentions, etc. -the Twitter KPIs. [34] The more you link to your Twitter handle and promote it, the more followers you?ll bring in. [29] Increasing your followers on Twitter naturally isn?t easy, but it?s worth it in the end. [29]

You will notice that such accounts follow a lot of people but don?t have many followers in return. [36] It’ll remove suspicious users from follower counts, but not completely erase the accounts. [33] A good rule of thumb is that an account with 1,000 followers should receive at least 25 likes per tweet. [36] A New York Times investigation published Saturday found that celebrities are turning to a “shadowy global marketplace” that offers them fake social media followers. [35] You need to take a hard look at your followers and figure out who is fake. [30] That?s right, Cleaner for IG will figure out which followers are fake and will give you the option to remove them. [30] Often a person who creates fake accounts create a script ( bot ) that automatically follows other people in the hopes that they will follow them back and increase their follower count. [31] The fake accounts that people buy for followers have to stay active so they follow people to keep from being deleted so undoubtedly some of them went her way. [51]

“For Influencer accounts that have organic growth, there tends to be a fairly consistent trend line of follower growth. [30] It is not uncommon for a celebrity account and big business to have several thousand or even millions of followers. [31] Since follower counts lead to influence in the real world, aspiring influencers, businesspeople, and politicians often purchased followers en masse, the Times says. [33] The Devumi website, however, says: “Our followers look like any other followers. the only way anyone will know is if you tell them,” the Times reports. [32]

Advertisers who sponsored posts with these supposedly influential users soon realized not every follower was a real person, and they weren’t reaching the numbers they were paying for. [33] FollowerSale : FollowerSale uses a credit system to encourage real users to follow their customers, providing live, active followers as a result. [29]

From now on, those locked accounts won?t be counted as followers of any account they had followed. [52] In 2018, most brands and marketers are concerned with engagement and interaction vs. the number of followers a blogger or influencer boasts. [30] Analyzing your followers, tweets, and hashtags can help you generate better engagement on this social media platform. [34] It’s clear that the higher engagement tweet is the one your followers like better. [34]

Twitter will purge tens of millions of fake or suspicious accounts starting Thursday, The New York Times reports. [33] If the fake account is on a social network like Facebook, Instagram, or Twitter, look at their friend’s list or who follows them. [31] Note: When an account is created on Facebook it is created using an ID system instead of a unique identifier like Twitter. [31]

Birdsong Analytics can tell you what percentage of your followers are active Twitter users, based on when they last tweeted and how many people they follow. [34] Obtaining a high number of followers is a landmark goal of many Twitter users. [29] This week we?ll be removing locked Twitter accounts (locked when we detect suspicious changes in behavior) from follower counts across profiles globally. [52]

The day you stop following more people, your follower count goes stale. [34] You keep following people hoping to increase your reach and improve your follower growth rate. [34] People can make real money from how many followers they have. [32] Most fake accounts will have very few followers and always have fewer followers than the real person or company. [31] Just a handful of engaged, active followers is infinitely more valuable than hundreds of fake accounts that do nothing more than add to an ego-stroking number. [29]

The number of followers displayed on many profiles may go down. [52] The above image shows the number of followers for every day of the last thirty days. [34] Increasing the number of influential followers is a pretty decent recipe for success. [34] If you’re signed up to a platform like Fohr (and want to keep a strong follower health score), Cleaner for IG will become your best friend. [30] When you have influential followers, their retweets, likes, mentions, etc., of you will help you multiply your reach. [34] Birdsong can give you the time of day when most of your followers tweet themselves. [34] The Times found that the email address for Ashley Knight, Lewis? personal assistant, was listed on an order for 250,000 followers from Devumi. [35] The times when your followers are active may not correlate with their time zones. [34] This report shows the active times of your followers based on your own time zone. [34] In the past having a lot of followers used to confer a certain amount of “social proof?. [36] “When you buy followers or fans, you aren?t getting people who are interested or willing to engage with you. [30] Fast Followerz : This group claims to provide real, active followers that regularly tweet, update, and are engaged. [29]

Below are the steps and helpful tips you can follow to help determine if an account is real or fake. [31]

RANKED SELECTED SOURCES(52 source documents arranged by frequency of occurrence in the above report)

1. (108) 4 Reasons Why You Should Not Buy Followers

2. (57) How to Get More Real Twitter Followers – ShareThis

3. (48) A “Dirty and Open Secret?: Can Social Media Curb Fake Followers? – [email protected]

4. (41) Marketers Guide: How To Detect Fake Influencers & Followers

5. (37) Here?s Why You Ought to Delete Fake Followers

6. (36) Fake Followers: How to Avoid Them Through Successful Vetting

7. (32) Buying Twitter Followers: The (Cheap) Price of Friendship

8. (28) Unmasking Fake Twitter Followers, Social Media Fraud & Fake Profiles

9. (27) Battling Fake Accounts, Twitter to Slash Millions of Followers – The New York Times

10. (27) All Twitter Followers Are Fake Followers – The Atlantic

11. (25) Trumps Twitter Following Includes At Least 13.7 Million Fake Accounts

12. (23) How to tell if someone’s Twitter, Instagram or Facebook account has fake followers

13. (19) 55 Celebrities and More Who Have Fake Followers, According to The New York Times

14. (19) Twitter Followers Vanish Amid Inquiries Into Fake Accounts – The New York Times

15. (19) Media companies have a fake follower Twitter problem, too (TWTR) — Quartz

16. (18) Twitter culls fake followers, Democrats hardest hit

17. (18) 5 Ways To Tell If An Influencer Has Fake Followers

18. (17) Concerns over ID theft and fake Twitter followers lead to NYS probe

19. (17) Your Twitter Followers May Be Damaging your Engagement and Reach

20. (16) Lies, Dumb Lies, and Richard Roeper?s Twitter Following – The Ringer

21. (15) Start 2018 Off With a Cleanse of Your Social Media Followers | Inc.com

22. (15) The Complete Guide to Analyzing Your Twitter Account | ZoomOwl

23. (15) How to Detect Fake Influencers in 6 Easy Steps. – Upfluence

24. (15) [Bar Graph] AP Top 25 by Fake Twitter Followers : CollegeBasketball

25. (14) Tips & Tools for Detecting Fake Followers on Instagram

26. (14) Identify Fake Influencers: Analyzing Follower & Engagement Stats | PPM

27. (14) How to Spot a Fake Twitter Follower and Assess the Value of a Real One | The California Report | KQED News

28. (13) Twitter Audit | How many of your followers are real?

29. (13) 5 Tips to Detect Fake Followers – The InfluencerBay Blog

30. (12) How I Bought 1,000 Twitter Followers

31. (12) How To Get Rid Of Fake Followers on Instagram and Twitter FAST

32. (11) How to Tell How Many Followers You Lost in the Great Twitter “Purge” of 2018 | The Digital Reader

33. (10) How to know if someone has fake followers on Twitter – Quora

34. (9) How to tell if you have fake Twitter followers (and how to remove them) | Poynter

35. (9) Follower Bots Exposed: How to Spot Fake Influencers – The Social Shake-Up Show

36. (8) Twitter Says Reports Claiming Indian Leaders Have Fake Followers Are Deeply Flawed | Technology News

37. (8) Are Donald Trump’s Followers Real? Report Finds Almost Half of His Social Media Following Could Be Fake

38. (8) Twitter removes fake accounts, users may see drop in followers

39. (8) https://lifehacker.com/how-to-block-your-fake-followers-1822739611

40. (8) How To Spot Fake Facebook Likes, Twitter Followers and YouTube Plays | Michael Brandvold Marketing

41. (7) Celebrities Lose Millions of Fake Followers in Twitter Purge | Time

42. (7) How big a sin is it to buy Twitter followers? – Chicago Tribune

43. (7) How do you know if an account is real or fake

44. (7) Your Twitter follower count will probably drop Thursday. Here’s why.

45. (7) Twitter cracking down on locked accounts, cutting follower numbers – Business Insider

46. (7) Twitter users to see drop in followers amid crackdown on ‘problem’ accounts | Technology | The Guardian

47. (7) Twitter follower counts drop after a change in how they are counted – The Verge

48. (6) The Ultimate Twitter Audit Guide: Tips from the Pros | Crowdbabble

49. (5) Nearly 50 million fake Twitter accounts are being sold to real users – Axios

50. (5) How to Prevent Strangers From Following You on Twitter

51. (4) Ray Lewis has over 700,000 Twitter followers. A lot of them are fake accounts – Baltimore Sun

52. (2) Apparently over half of Gagas followers are fake. Thoughts? – Gaga Thoughts – Gaga Daily